Become a Member
Judaism

Why Israel should look east for a model of religious moderation

April 14, 2016 11:18
Israeli campaigner and NIF human rights award winner Eli Bareket

By

Simon Rocker,

Simon Rocker

3 min read

When Eli Bareket was growing up in Israel, he reached the final of a pre-Pesach school quiz. One of the questions, about the Seder song Echad Mi Yadea, asked "who knows two"?

Two are the tablets which Moses brought down from Sinai, of course. But that was not what young Eli wrote. He put down "Moses and Aaron". "Wrong," said the teacher.

Except that he was right. His family, originally from Libya, sang the song at their Seder in Arabic and that version has two brothers rather than two tablets. But the teacher had no idea of the variant. When a child is led to believe that what he is taught at home is incorrect, Mr Bareket said, "he begins to doubt his parents, his tradition, his culture".

Jews whose families came to Israel from Arab lands often had to contend with such ignorance. The Judaism that evolved in Islamic countries was widely considered inferior to the Judaism of the West.