Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Board row over use of IHRA definition

Argument follows VP's criticism of Israel's Nation State law

    Two deputies who have pushed for a no confidence vote against a Board vice president for criticising Israel’s controversial Nation State law are now themselves subject to a “motion of censure”.

    The bid to force a vote against vice president Sheila Gewolb was brought in late August by Jacob Lyons, deputy for Western Marble Arch Synagogue, and seconded by Martin Rankoff, who represents Redbridge Synagogue.

    Mr Lyons argues that Dr Gewolb breached the IHRA definition of antisemitism in saying that “some of the measures” in the Nation State law were “regressive steps”.

    He claimed her comments “[applies] double standards to Israel by requiring of it a behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.”

    The Nation State law has been criticised for asserting that the right to national self-determination in the country is “unique to the Jewish people” — as well as demoting Arabic from the status of official language.

    In response, an anonymous group of “concerned deputies”, have proposed a “motion of censure” against Mr Lyons and Mr Rankoff, arguing they have misused the IHRA definition of antisemitism.

    In a letter to fellow deputies, they wrote: “The claim that in voicing this opinion Dr Gewolb was expressing antisemitic views is not just false, but in fact severely damaging to the on-going fight against antisemitism in the UK.

    “We consider that a public debate on this motion would be deeply embarrassing and counterproductive to the communal unity and broad support which IHRA has until now enjoyed.”

    The JC understands that Mr Lyons is yet to submit the 50 votes required to trigger a vote of no confidence in Dr Gewolb.

    Further, there is believed to be no protocol under the Board’s constitution for bringing motions of censure against individual deputies.

Israel

Bennett: There is an 'unprecedented crisis' between Israel and diaspora

Ben Weich

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Bennett: There is an 'unprecedented crisis' between Israel and diaspora
Israel

American progressives defend Airbnb's removal of West Bank properties

Ben Weich

Friday, December 7, 2018

American progressives defend Airbnb's removal of West Bank properties
UK News

Comedian apologises for guest who shared antisemitic conspiracy theories

Ben Weich

Thursday, December 6, 2018

Comedian apologises for guest who shared antisemitic conspiracy theories
UK News

Martin Lewis opens up about losing his mother as a child

Ben Weich

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Martin Lewis opens up about losing his mother as a child
UK News

Suspended Deputy may be allowed back if she says sorry for 'Islamophobic' comments

Ben Weich

Friday, December 7, 2018

Suspended Deputy may be allowed back if she says sorry for 'Islamophobic' comments
UK News

Israeli measles epidemic hits London's Charedi community

Ben Weich

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

Israeli measles epidemic hits London's Charedi community
World

Antisemites take part in gilets jaunes protests

Ben Weich

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Antisemites take part in gilets jaunes protests
UK News

Lawyers 'demand damages' from university over ambassador's cancelled talk

Ben Weich

Thursday, December 6, 2018

Lawyers 'demand damages' from university over ambassador's cancelled talk
UK News

Labour antisemitism dossier: Police believe crimes may have been committed

Ben Weich

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

Labour antisemitism dossier: Police believe crimes may have been committed