Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Academic: Doctors who circumcise should be struck off

    Critics have rounded on an academic who has warned that doctors could be guilty of negligence and be breaking the Human Rights Act for performing circumcisions for anything other than medical reasons.

    Dr David Shaw, an expert in medical ethics at Glasgow University, called for the General Medical Council (GMC) and the British Medical Association (BMA) to tighten up the advice they give doctors about circumcision.

    He argued that the BMA had admitted openly that non-therapeutic circumcision “may be against the law” and that its guidance said that doctors who perform circumcision may be in breach of the Human Rights Act.

    On the GMC guidelines, he wrote that while Jews and Muslims “might well regard a restriction on circumcision as a breach of human rights...” it was unlikely there was a “fundamental human right to be circumcised”.

    But the BMA said Dr Shaw had got it wrong. A BMA spokeswoman said: “We do not believe that performing a circumcision for non-therapeutic reasons is contrary to the Human Rights Act. Nor do we believe doctors who carry it out may be acting illegally.

    “Dr Shaw did not check with us first. It will now be up to our ethics department to contact him about this.”

    Jon Benjamin, chief executive of the Board of Deputies, said: “Dr Shaw’s view of the ethics of brit milah is flawed.

    “His definition of ‘best interests’ omits the fundamental consideration of a child’s religious or cultural wellbeing.

    “Dr Shaw holds a minority view and the Jewish community should not allow itself to be intimidated by it.”

Uk News

Strictly Orthodox Ukip candidate 'should not run for office'

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

Strictly Orthodox Ukip candidate 'should not run for office'
Special Reports

Dublin benefits from overseas aid

Barry Toberman

Sunday, January 8, 2017

Dublin benefits from overseas aid
Uk News

Luciana Berger troll driven by 'fierce antisemitism'

JC Reporter

Monday, December 5, 2016

Luciana Berger troll driven by 'fierce antisemitism'
Uk News

Government drops pledge to aid 3,000 child refugees

Rosa Doherty

Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Government drops pledge to aid 3,000 child refugees
Uk News

Limmud: Food for thought at session on 'ethical eating'

By Simon Rocker

Tuesday, December 27, 2016

Limmud: Food for thought at session on 'ethical eating'
Uk News

Local MP blocks visit from David Irving's 'secret tour'

Rosa Doherty

Friday, December 2, 2016

Local MP blocks visit from David Irving's 'secret tour'
Uk News

Anti-Israel conference faces delay

Lee Harpin

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Anti-Israel conference faces delay
Uk News

Commission criticised over inquiry into 'antisemitic' charity

Daniel Sugarman

Monday, December 5, 2016

Commission criticised over inquiry into 'antisemitic' charity
Uk News

Fawlty Towers star Andrew Sachs dies aged 86

JC Reporter

Friday, December 2, 2016

Fawlty Towers star Andrew Sachs dies aged 86