Become a Member
News

Faulty towers and building bridges: the year in politics

December 29, 2011 12:40
Rowed back over Gaza: Cameron

By

Martin Bright,

Martin Bright

6 min read

The political year ended with the miserable spectacle of two members of Parliament being forced to apologise to the Jewish community for their actions: one for peddling the ancient antisemitic libel of the "dual loyalty" of Jews; the other for attending a Nazi-themed stag party.

There was much discussion in Westminster circles about who was worse: Labour's Paul Flynn for accusing the UK's first Jewish ambassador to Israel of disloyalty or Conservative Aidan Burley for not acting when friends toasted the Third Reich over dinner at a French ski resort.

Mr Flynn's language was decidedly medieval in its evocation of fears of Jewish duplicity, whereas Mr Burley's friends celebrated the perpetrators of more recent atrocities. Neither should have a place in a 21st century democracy. It is right that their parties acted to persuade Flynn and Burley to apologise to the UK's Jews. But it remains shocking that these two mainstream politicians couldn't see for themselves the repellent historic resonances of their actions.

Other backbenchers also found themselves in a terrible muddle when they tried to set up an All-Party Parliamentary Group on Islamophobia based on the highly successful APPG on Antisemitism run by the redoubtable Labour MP John Mann. This should have been a straightforward affair and an important step in the fight against anti-Muslim hate crime. Unfortunately, however, the group chose the avowedly anti-Zionist organisation "i-Engage" to act as its secretariat. This led to the resignation in February of founders Lord Janner and Conservative MP Kris Hopkins as co-chairs of the group. Amid bitter recriminations, Liberal Democrat Simon Hughes initially stuck by i-Engage but was eventually forced to abandon the controversial organisation after Conservative and Labour MPs raised concerns. The APPG has now been relaunched without its anti-Zionist partner. Meanwhile, a year of important work has been wasted.

To get more news, click here to sign up for our free daily newsletter.