Farewell from the JC’s man of letters

I have often been asked how I decide which books should be reviewed in the JC and I usually reply: “instinct”, which, of course, strengthens with experience. The only criterion, be it a novel, biography, history, political argument or anything else, fiction or non-fiction, is that its subject matter must be of interest or relevance to at least part of our exceptionally wide readership. It could be something by a Jewish author with little or no overtly Jewish content, or by a non-Jewish author with plenty of it – and much else in between.

As for what are sometimes called the “really Jewish” books, from Siddurim and Haggadot to religious and biblical exegesis, these go straight to the Judaism editor. This hasn’t prevented many a rabbi appearing on my pages, whether reviewing or being reviewed. The late Rabbi David Goldberg, senior minister at the Liberal Jewish Synagogue in St John’s Wood, who died in 2019, wrote several highly intelligent and sometimes provocative pieces for me. On one occasion, when Goldberg had delivered a negative verdict on what he considered a pretentious mountain of words, the offended author threatened to take him (and me) to the London Beth Din. “Bring it on,” was David’s response, and he was genuinely disappointed when the threat was not carried through.

Looking back over the whole of my long stint as Lit Ed, it is possible to discern patterns and trends, innovations and changes throughout the publishing industry, though much of its Jewish product in the 20th and 21st centuries has been unpredictable, especially if you go back well before even my time at the helm. Who, for example, could have foreseen that a pamphlet written by a Hungarian journalist with negligible Hebrew would kick-start the modern Zionist movement? Or that, among personal accounts of the Second World War, the one with the greatest emotional impact would be a diary written by a teenage girl? And that a major shift in Jewish literary sensibility would be initiated by a book written by a non-Jewish, Australian novelist?

But whereas the achievements of the journalist Theodor Herzl and the teenage Anne Frank derived directly from their original texts, novelist Thomas Keneally’s Schindler’s Ark, telling the true story of a Nazi who saved 1,200 Jewish lives, is one of those powerful books that trigger a process in which the dramatic and cinematic arts supersede the literary. Despite Schindler’s Ark having won the Booker Prize in 1982, it wasn’t until the release in 1993 of Steven Spielberg’s film, Schindler’s List, based on Keneally’s book, that writing about the Shoah became widely acceptable. Before Schindler’s List, most British publishers scrupulously avoided Holocaust material.

The success of Schindler’s List changed the climate. Encouraged by Spielberg himself, a gentle flow of Shoah memoirs gathered strength and became a flood. Even now, seven or eight decades after the events described, the Holocaust still constitutes the subject matter foremost among the books sent to the JC’s literary editor’s desk. But, while Keneally’s book was firmly rooted in fact, the waters have since become muddied by often undisciplined, implausible and melodramatic Holocaust-themed fiction, which is now a genre in its own right.

A contrasting, uncontaminated flow on to the pages of our paper has been that of Israeli literature, led in my time by the likes of Amos Oz and David Grossman.

All this I have been privileged to encounter through British Jewry’s organ.

The JC was also instrumental in igniting my external writing career when, in the early 1980s, the then editor, Geoffrey Paul, introduced me to the publisher George Weidenfeld. And it is to that area of my life I now return, taking with me an imprint of the letters JC on my heart.