French Parliament says Israel is not 'apartheid' state

The members of the National Assembly overwhelmingly rejected a controversial resolution 199 to 71


French National Assembly President Yael Braun-Pivet addresses the audience during a Franco-German parliamentary session as part of the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the signing of the Elysee Treaty which sealed reconciliation between France and West Germany, 18 years after the Second World War, at the National Assembly in Paris on January 22, 2023. - The date of the reunion is highly symbolic: sixty years to the day after Charles de Gaulle and Konrad Adenauer signed the Elysee Treaty, which "marked the end of decades, if not centuries, of fierce rivalries and bloody wars", write the two leaders in an op-ed published by the German daily Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung and the French Journal du dimanche. (Photo by Thomas SAMSON / AFP) (Photo by THOMAS SAMSON/AFP via Getty Images)

(JNS) The French parliament has overwhelmingly rejected a resolution calling Israel an 'apartheid' state.

Yesterday, after a group of left-wing members of France’s National Assembly put forward the measure labeling Israel an “apartheid state,” the lower house of Parliament rejected it by a margin of 199 to 71.

Arguing for the resolution, Jean-Paul Lecoq, of the Communist Party, said that “the settlement policy is contrary to international legality” and “legally comes under a situation of apartheid.” He called the Israeli government “an institutionalized regime” that is “aimed at the oppression of one group over another,” and called for France to recognize “the state of Palestine.”

Jérôme Guedj, of the Socialist Party, rejected Lecoq’s invocation of “apartheid,” calling it an effort to “racialize and essentialize” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and Aurore Bergé, president of the Renaissance party, called the measure “defamation,” declaring, “France is the friend of Israel.”

Centrist and right-wing members of parliament condemned the resolution in the debate. Aurore Bergé, president of the centrist Renaissance Party, argued that the bill represented a “gesture of hate against the State of Israel.”

Meyer Habib, a Tunisian-Jewish MP who represents French citizens overseas said that it proved “antisemitism today is mainly on the left.”

“We can only reject the use of the term apartheid to describe the situation in Israel,” Laurence Boone, French secretary of state for European affairs, tweeted. “This term carries a heavy load, attached to terrible suffering and bruised memories.”

“We commend France’s National Assembly for voting overwhelmingly to reject a resolution that would have falsely applied the ‘apartheid’ label to Israel,” wrote the American Jewish Committee. “France remains a close friend and vital partner of the Jewish state, a pillar of the Israel-Europe relationship.”

And the European Jewish Congress expressed “deepest gratitude” to the assembly members, “who voted against the false and damaging label of apartheid being attached to Israel and had the courage to denounce its anti-Zionist nature,” and added, “Today, France sent a powerful message of solidarity with Israel and in favor of fairness.”

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive