I wrote the post below about BBC Young Musician of the Year before watching the final, broadcast yesterday.
Given that it had been allocated two hours on BBC2, I assumed we would be allowed to hear more than the same inane rubbish broadcast during the heats. As if.
In days of old (yes, in this respect at least things really were better in the olden days) the programme consisted of the finalists playing a concerto each, some expert commentary, and the results. I have no idea what the ratings were, but why should that matter to a public service broadcaster?
Not any more. Yesterday's programme consisted of mindless chit chat with the contestants' relatives about how they would be feeling, some patronising intro and lame jokes (so lame that they were met with silence in the hall) by Aled Jones and five minutes or so given over to an instrumental solo by the contestants. As for the concertos, we are clearly all too stupid and hyperactive to sit and listen to a whole piece. So the contestants simply performed an extract from their chosen piece. (They had apparently played the full piece the night before, but the BBC decided not to bother with that as it would clearly have frightened away any audience.)
We pay for this. We pay, under threat of a jail sentence, to be treated as morons. We pay to have anything remotely serious reduced to pap.
If the BBC was given charge of a three star Michelin restaurant, it would puree all the food and feed it to its customerrs through straws.
To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.
