closeicon
News

Steve Bell cartoon was ‘highly provocative’, admits one Guardian editor

The illustration depicted Starmer carrying Corbyn’s dismembered head on a plate

articlemain

HULL, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 03: Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn steps off a train from Leeds as he tours the North of England by rail today on September 3, 2018 in Hull, England. Labour under Mr Corbyn are proposing a 'Crossrail for the North' linking the North East and North West of England with a new rail line. (Photo by Jack Taylor/Getty Images)

A Guardian editor has acknowledged Steve Bell’s cartoon responding to Jeremy Corbyn’s suspension from the Labour Party was "highly provocative".

The illustration - which critics accused of antisemitism - depicted Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer carrying his predecessor’s dismembered head on a plate. 

It drew comparisons to Caravaggio’s painting of Salome and John the Baptist, in which the princess of Judea is shown looking away as she receives the preacher’s decapitated head.

Thirty-two readers complained the cartoon featured “antisemitic imagery”, the Guardian and Observer’s global readers editor Elisabeth Ribbans said in a column on Thursday.

But, according to the column, Mr Bell strongly denied the accusation and maintained the piece had “nothing to do with religion and everything to do with politics”.

Mr Bell faced similar claims in the past, which he rejected. 

Prior to the cartoon’s publication, there had been “considerable discussion, including with some Jewish colleagues and experts”, the editor confirmed.

“I do not believe Bell to be antisemitic or that he intended his Starmer to embody any noxious myth about Jews,” she added.

“However, using a Jewish biblical figure who conspired against a saint was highly provocative and open to just the kind of interpretations made.”

Mr Corbyn’s suspension was sparked by his response to a damning report into antisemitism, which found “unlawful” acts of discrimination and harassment. He wrote on Facebook that anti-Jewish racism within the party was “dramatically overstated” by his opponents and the media.

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive