Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Survey: Charedi textbooks ‘demonise Reform Jews’

Curricula were found to oppose modernity, instead promoting “a separate cultural identity”, which ignores trends in general society

    Textbooks in Israeli Charedi schools demonise Reform Jews, show limited acceptance of others and keep contact with mainstream Israeli culture to a minimum, according to a new survey.

    The Israeli-based Institute for Monitoring Peace and Cultural Tolerance in School Education (Impact-se) analysed 93 textbooks used in the strictly Orthodox system.

    Curricula oppose modernity, instead promoting “a separate cultural identity”, which ignores trends in general society.

    Marcus Sheff, Impact-se’s chief executive, commented there was “a general commitment to peaceful conduct and co-existence” and “despite what we are seeing on the streets of Israel recently, there is no incitement to violence in the textbooks”.

    But he added, “the price of Charedi isolationism seems to be the negation of the other, vilification of the Reform movement in particular, the unnecessary use of stereotypes and, occasionally, offensive language”.

    Women were portrayed as responsible for raising children at home, while their role as earners who supported studying husbands was emphasised.

    While peace and territorial compromise in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was not ruled out, these were “perceived as the naïve longing of leftist Israelis”, Impact-se found.

    While there was “the expectation of behaving fairly toward all people, there is no attempt to uproot stereotypes and promote equality,” the report concluded.

Analysis

Questions linger, not least over ‘gay love’

Simon Rocker

Thu, 14:22

Questions linger, not least over ‘gay love’
Uk News

Panel: Dweck can remain as leader

Simon Rocker

Wed, 11:55

Panel: Dweck can remain as leader
Uk News

Concern over US rabbi’s Reform slur

Simon Rocker

Friday, July 14, 2017

Concern over US rabbi’s Reform slur
Comment

Are Jews an ethnic minority

Simon Rocker

Thu, 14:01

Are Jews an ethnic minority
Education news

Mayor blocks Hasmo redevelopment

Simon Rocker

Tue, 10:56

Mayor blocks Hasmo redevelopment
Analysis

End in sight to the Dweck affair?

Simon Rocker

Thursday, July 13, 2017

End in sight to the Dweck affair?
Uk News

Sacks and Goldstein support Mirvis

Simon Rocker

Wed, 16:55

Sacks and Goldstein support Mirvis
Education news

Now high schools get the quiz bug

Simon Rocker

Friday, July 14, 2017

Now high schools get the quiz bug
Community News

New Jewish school for Brighton?

Simon Rocker

Wednesday, July 12, 2017

New Jewish school for Brighton?