Become a Member
Life

Unbelievers review: A mother in the grip of her worst nightmare ★★★

Nicola Walker conveys with fevered obsession how a mother’s mind implodes when her teenage son disappears

October 22, 2025 15:18
1129-431.P_c_Brinkhoff-Moegenburg (1).JPG
Tortured: Nicola Walker as Miriam, whose teenage son disappears (Photo: Brinkhoff Moegenburg)
1 min read

Nick Payne is the top-drawer dramatist who expanded minds with his multiverse-traversing Constellations. His latest play explores how a mother’s mind implodes when her teenage son disappears.

In Marianne Elliot’s somewhat tiring production, Nicola Walker conveys every parent’s greatest nightmare with a fevered obsession. Her Miriam cuts a solitary figure even when she is surrounded by her fractured family, which consists of her hand-wringing husband David (Paul Higgins), their daughter Margaret (Ella Lily Hykand) and Margaret’s half-sister Nancy (Alby Baldwin).

The clear-headed urgency with which Miriam conducted her initial search atrophies into a suspended state of bewilderment, but also a determination to either find her son or wait for him, for no matter how long.

Payne is a master at keeping his audience on its toes. The final line of dialogue in one scene often turns out to be the first spoken line in the next. In this disorienting way the narrative vaults forward in time and back until a portrait of a family coping – or not – with the disappearance of their number fully emerges.

To get more from Life, click here to sign up for our free Life newsletter.

Topics:

Theatre