The Jewish actor stands out in this beautifully performed play about Jews at Christmas
October 29, 2025 16:19
The description of the late Richard Greenberg, who died this year, as the Noël Coward of his generation says a lot about the New York playwright’s wit but nothing about his Jewishness. This UK debut of his 2013 play, which imagines what Christmas might be like for Upper West Side Jews, does both.
In Blanche MacIntyre’s beautifully performed production the somewhat detached Jewish relationship to Christmas – for those Jews who dabble – is never absent. The towering Christmas tree centre stage is the soulless, gaudy plant of a household where the ritual is only adopted and never truly felt. When the play shifts from Christmas Day in 1980 to exactly 20 years later, Tracy-Ann Oberman’s Faye flings the tinsel on that year’s tree with the care of someone chucking dirty laundry into a basket.
Oberman is in the form of her life as the savvy, bling-bedecked sister to Julie (Broadway’s Jennifer Westfeldt) whose love of the Christian holiday is a chance to play domestic goddess and indulge the delusion that all is well with her apparently gilded existence.
Yet Julie’s sick young son Timmy is in bed while his older brother Scotty (Alexander Marks) may not be Harvard material after all. Meanwhile, the sisters’ husbands are almost at war. In a change of gear the revolving set sweeps us to the living room where Faye’s blue-collar spouse Mort (a pitch- perfect David Kennedy who could star in a Jewish version of The Sopranos) is blackmailing Julie’s Ben (Daniel Abelson) over a matter of the necklace that Julie has but which Mort thinks should belong to Faye.
Any vestige of doubt about the disconnect between these Jews and the festival is expunged with Julie’s view of Bing Crosby’s ubiquitous dream of a white Christmas, which every time she hears it is “like a tiny acoustic rape”. The dialogue here is sharper than holly.
In a perfect piece of plotting the backstory to the mysterious necklace meeting turns out to be the backbone of the second act. To all this Greenberg adds a hint of Chekhovian tragedy in the form of Scotty’s adoring best friend Jeff (Sam Marks), who becomes the best friend of Scotty’s family.
If I have one gripe it is that James Cotterill’s dour set feels more like a residential home for the elderly than a desirable New York apartment. Yet the fizz of the performances led by Oberman’s grounded and clever Faye keeps the stage as vibrant as Times Square.
This is the first of two plays about Jews at Christmas this year. The second is Sam Grabiner’s new London-set Christmas Day, which opens at the Almeida in December. Located in an abandoned building above the Northern line it sounds as if it will be a very different take on what diaspora Jews do during the inescapable holiday.
The Assembled Parties
Hampstead Theatre
To get more from Life, click here to sign up for our free Life newsletter.