Become a Member
The Jewish Chronicle

Be clear: dead soldiers don’t ‘come back home’

July 24, 2008 23:00

By

David Landau,

David Landau

2 min read

Israelis must stop pretending that bringing back soldiers' bodies is as important as freeing live captives


If words are indeed a window to the soul, then perhaps one can understand - but not justify - the murder of our language that took place last week.

"Udi and Eldad come home." This deliberate butchery of words and the cynical distortion of their meaning is an etymological-psychological symptom of the suicidal tendencies gnawing at Israel's soul, culminating in a swap of the living for the dead.

Of course, a line runs from the infamous Ahmed Jibril prisoner exchange in 1985, when Israel swapped 1,150 prisoners for three soldiers, to the Nasrallah deal, which will be remembered with shame. The line also passes through the deal that led to the release of Elchanan Tennenbaum in 2004.

The picture that emerges is one of a breakdown in the resolve of Israel's leadership and its ability to fend off pressure from the soldiers' families (who are blameless).