Become a Member

By

Mark Berg

Opinion

Questions for protesters

August 7, 2014 15:16
2 min read

Let's get the labelling stuff on the table straight off. I'm a Jew, and I'm a Zionist. I care deeply about the state of Israel for two main reasons. Firstly, because I care for the welfare of my fellow Jews, and, secondly, because if life grows uncomfortable for me as a Jew in the UK, I will have somewhere safe to run to.

I'm also a passionate believer in a two-state solution because there's no denying that the Palestinian Arabs have been displaced and left stateless by the creation of the state of Israel (irrespective of the fact that they could have had their own state in 1947 when it was offered by the UN). I'm bitterly disappointed that, although Israel and the PA have come close on numerous occasions, a deal has thus far eluded them, with a huge and growing price in blood.

Like any right-minded person, I deplore the death and destruction in Gaza I've witnessed on my TV screen. It upsets me doubly to see such suffering and to know that, whatever the sequence of events, my own brethren have inflicted so much sorrow on the civilians of Gaza.

It's understandable, then, that protesters might take to the streets. As a democrat, I would defend to my core their right to protest (even though my analysis of the situation differs from theirs). Yet the tone of many of the protests (e.g. equating Israelis with the Nazis) leaves me profoundly disturbed. It seems to me that Israel's actions stir the passions of people in a way that nothing else can and I want to understand why.