The suffering of Palestinians in Gaza whose shelters have been flooded by winter rain is undeniable and their plight demands attention. It does not, however, justify the inflammatory accusations that have become a familiar feature of Ed Miliband’s pronouncements on Israel.
Last week, the foreign secretary accused Israel of imposing “arbitrary restrictions” on humanitarian access. On Sunday, in a joint statement with his counterparts from Australia, Canada and Italy, he demanded that Israel permit the entry of even dual-use materials into Gaza.
One may disagree with Israel’s decisions and justification, but to dismiss them as arbitrary is not serious diplomacy. It is an inflammatory accusation that suggests Israel is denying Palestinians supplies on a whim, without legitimate reason or discernible criteria, when Israel has explicitly set out its security concerns about materials that Hamas has previously diverted to construct tunnels, manufacture rockets and prepare attacks against Israeli civilians.
In fact, by singling out dual-use materials in his subsequent statement, Miliband tacitly acknowledges that Israel’s restrictions are not arbitrary after all, yet he still fails to acknowledge the security risks that explain them. Such materials are called dual-use for a reason – what can serve civilian needs can sometimes also help Hamas rebuild its military infrastructure, which would endanger not only Israeli civilians but Palestinians, who would once again bear the consequences of another war initiated by Hamas. The terror group has made no secret of its methods and, in propaganda footage, even boasted of digging up water pipes to build rockets. That same disregard for civilian needs was evident in its neglect of Gaza’s drainage infrastructure, which contributed to recurrent flooding long before the war.
Worse, Miliband’s demands, without so much as mentioning Hamas by name, let alone condemning its theft and misuse of supplies, risk creating a dangerous incentive for the Islamist terrorists to aggravate the humanitarian crisis. Former shadow foreign secretary Dame Priti Patel told the JC it was “shameful” that Miliband and Labour were “promoting the narratives and spin put out by Hamas terrorists”.
Indeed, if worsening civilian conditions increases international pressure on Israel to admit materials that Hamas could exploit militarily, it stands to gain from prolonging the very suffering it has helped create, without having to fulfil its own ceasefire obligations.
The same perverse incentive was at work throughout the war. Hamas triggered the conflict with the October 7 massacre, then hid behind Gaza’s population, knowing that the inevitable civilian casualties would bring international condemnation down on Israel rather than on those who had started the war. By directing their outrage almost exclusively at Israel while largely absolving Hamas of responsibility, Western leaders rewarded the very tactics they should have been seeking to end, encouraging Hamas to continue exploiting civilians rather than end the conflict.
Nor does Miliband acknowledge the considerable assistance Israel has already facilitated. According to the IDF, more than 93,000 tents, 8,600 truckloads of winter supplies and 16 sewage vacuum trucks have entered Gaza in recent weeks. The military also said that international organisations have yet to deliver some of the supplies it had already approved, in part because of their own financial and logistical difficulties. These assertions, too, deserve proper examination rather than the automatic assumption that every delay is Israel’s responsibility.
The international peace plan rightly recognises that Gaza’s reconstruction depends upon Hamas’s disarmament and removal from power. That is not an obstacle to improving Palestinian lives, but the necessary foundation for doing so.
Miliband’s apparent inability to grasp this distinction is deeply troubling. A foreign policy that demands humanitarian access while ignoring the terrorist organisation responsible for exploiting civilian infrastructure risks perpetuating the very suffering it professes to alleviate. The people of Gaza deserve shelter and Israelis and Palestinians alike deserve a future free from the threat of another war.
To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.

