An expert unpicks a part of genetics that has a particular impact on the Jewish community
December 22, 2025 11:37
We talk about BRCA a lot in the Jewish community, but I speak to many people who still don’t fully understand what it means. We always want to know why we get illnesses – essentially what causes them. Doctors talk about genetics and environmental causes. An environmental cause is usually something from outside your body that you are not born with.
For example, you might knock your head and develop a headache, or you can get skin cancer from sun exposure. Genetic causes are different: you are born with this tendency in the DNA or genes you inherit from your parents – we might call this a gene mutation, a variant or an abnormal gene. Many diseases have both environmental and genetic causes, even in the same person. With the sun exposure you might also have a faulty gene that makes you more likely to get the skin cancer. If we know what causes an illness, it helps to prevent and treat it.
BRCA can be a genetic cause of cancers. Every one of us, men and women, has a BRCA 1 and a BRCA 2 gene. They are actually normal genes that protect our cells from developing cancer, but when they are abnormal, this goes wrong. So, if you have an abnormal or BRCA gene variant, you have a higher chance of getting cancer. Often people inherit this from a parent. But genes can also change (mutate) spontaneously, so some people have BRCA mutations and are the only one in their family. If you have an abnormal BRCA 1 or BRCA 2 gene, you are at higher risk of developing breast cancer particularly, but also ovarian cancer, and, to a lesser degree, pancreatic. If you are a man with a BRCA2 gene, it causes a higher-than-average risk of prostate cancer and male breast cancer. It’s important to know that you can inherit a BRCA variant from either parent. People sometimes think because it is associated with breast cancer, it must be from your mum, but that isn’t the case: it’s just as likely from your dad.
So, why does this matter to Jewish people? It is not uncommon to see diseases run in certain communities. Again, that can be for genetic and environmental reasons. An environmental reason might be because an ethnic group may all eat certain traditional foods which cause or protect from certain illnesses.
Genetically, diseases run in communities because we marry and have children with people from within the community, so there are not fresh genes coming in from all over the place. The gene pool remains quite closed and tight, and, as a result, if a mutated gene starts off in a community, it continues down the generations. It’s the same reason Jewish people carry certain physical traits, just like any ethnic group. And it will be different within Ashkenazim and Sephardim, because the communities started off as different distinct populations and in previous generations, have stayed and married within themselves. BRCA mutations are particularly prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews.
It’s important to know that it is not just BRCA variants that makes Jewish women more at risk from breast cancer. It seems there are other, perhaps unknown, genes or other factors that makes being Jewish itself a risk factor, whether you have BRCA or not. It could be environmental or genetic. So, you do hear of Jewish families – such as mine – where there is lots of breast cancer but no BRCA variants. The difference if you have BRCA is that the risk of breast cancer becomes especially high. If you have a BRCA variant, you should be looked after by a genetic clinic who can give you the facts about your risks and chances of developing cancer, as well as the risks for your family. Knowledge is power and we are lucky that we can test for BRCA and then do something about it.
Some people will opt for very regular screening to check regularly for early signs of cancer. Other people may opt for a more definitive approach of surgery: this is called risk-reduction surgery and would involve surgery to remove the breasts or ovaries. You can also now opt for medicine to reduce the chances of disease – this is called chemoprevention. Each family will be offered their own unique approach, as it depends on so many factors: and that’s not just the science, that’s also personal choice.
Dr Ellie Cannon sees patients privately at DGA Health (DGAhealth.com).
Her latest book, The Little Book of HRT, is out now
To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.
