Inciting times
Over the coming days there will be memorials for Yitzhak Rabin, who was assassinated on November 4, thirteen years ago. There will be ceremonies with speeches, poems and songs performed by religious and secular young people that focus on peace and tolerance, and there will be TV panels discussing whether lessons have been learnt, and how anything like this can be prevented from ever happening again.
But I can’t help wondering, what’s the point?
Yesterday’s Haaretz had a very disturbing front page. It wasn’t so much the content of the leading article, in which Shin Bet security chief Yuval Diskin suggested that more political assassinations may be on the horizon, but the photograph that accompanied it. Masked Israeli youths are seen throwing stones at cameramen and Israeli police at the West Bank outpost of Noam Federman’s Farm near Hebron, which had been demolished by Israeli security forces.
The chilling image is a reminder that the venom and the violence are happening again, if indeed they ever went away. I remember someone observing in the days after the assassination that Israelis seemed to be driving with less hooting and more courtesy, as though the shock of the murder had made everyone think about how to behave less aggressively in every area of life. It didn’t last, of course.
The problem is that public discourse in Israel is characterised by aggression and shouting. Politicians are among the worst offenders, as evidenced by what passes for debates in the Knesset and in panel discussions on TV. With elections now looming, the verbal aggression, at least, will only get worse.
I’ve been discussing the Rabin assassination with people recently. One friend commented that she wasn’t at all surprised that he was murdered. “People felt utter frustration because they had no way of expressing their opposition to the way he was dealing with the Palestinians.”
Taking this a stage further, then, what might Israelis living in the West Bank do to express their opposition if they are evicted from their homes by IDF soldiers? The photo in Haaretz gives us an idea of how some of them are already reacting. In the article, Diskin foresees that in addition to political assassinations, attacks on Arabs and attacks on Israel’s security forces are possible consequences of increasing Israeli violence in the West Bank.
“They wouldn’t attack our own soldiers,” my friend replied. “This was just an isolated incident.”
That’s more or less what I told my young kids a little over thirteen years ago, when we were at a public event attended by Yitzhak Rabin and we witnessed at first hand the shocking and frightening vitriol being directed at him. When my kids asked me tearfully that day whether someone would try to kill Rabin, I reassured them that while his life might be in some danger, the threat wasn’t from here - not from Israelis.
To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.