Become a Member
Opinion

I'm reviewing the situation …can Fagin be a villain all his life?

A trip to the theatre has Maureen musing on her heroes

July 23, 2025 12:07
Copy Of Oliver! 2024 (11) Simon Lipkin as Fagin. Credit Johan Persson (Read-Only)-a
Superb: Simon Lipkin as Fagin. (Photo: Johan Persson)
4 min read

We were at dinner at a friend’s house and the talk as ever drifted – or do I mean lurched, or even homed-in – on the collision that is Israel/Gaza. To say eight Jews, 16 opinions would be to underestimate and, of course, in the end the loudest voices have the last word. It comes down to “Is Bibi prolonging the war to save his skin?” or “Is this new antisemitism just an extension of the habitual ‘Let’s get the Jews’?”

Everyone around the table was Jewish and I thought, on the way home, that my life has become more tribal in the last couple of years. Planning a party brings one up short about how few of my friends understand me when I say, as I frequently do, “pass me the ongasplach”, meaning anything from a ladle to a bow tie. I don’t know what happened but my gentile friends seem far away.

So, I wondered, how does one play a stereotypical ethnic role now on stage or screen without labouring the typical bit? What would the response be today to Beattie the British Telecom anti-heroine, whom I played in 55, no less, commercials 30-odd years ago. Had there been such a thing in those days, it would have been described as having gone viral. To prove its power, not a week goes by without some wag with a giggling spouse behind him nudging me in a public spot and stage whispering: “Have you still got an ‘ology Maureen?”

But would she still be regarded with such affection today I wonder? Nosy, interfering, domineering, entitled matriarch that she was, would the award-winning campaign now even get off the ground? I doubt it somehow. The advertising world has turned and everything is now mostly directed to appeal to a multi-ethnic population. Which is how it should be in our patchwork evolution.

To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.