By ignoring film and TV ratings, Disney+ is opening up antisemitic, racist and homophobic content to kids
January 10, 2022 12:39U, PG, 15, 18 – the age ratings provided by the British Board of Film Classification constitute one of Britain’s best known and most trusted brands. For some young people, they are aspirational, a mark of good quality cinematography to come. For mums, dads, and carers across the UK, they can be an essential guide for responsible parenting. The BBFC doesn’t only provide age ratings for content released in UK cinemas, but also that released on DVD, and on a range of Video-on Demand and streaming platforms including Netflix, Amazon and Apple.
There is however a surprising outrider in the streaming world in Disney+. If we are discussing well known and trusted brands, one might think Disney beyond reproach, but it appears the company may not have the same regard for the wellbeing of children as we have come to believe through its many years of marketing entertainment to young people.
In the UK, Disney+ has taken the unusual step of applying its own arbitrary ratings to the content on its platform. These do not provide the same level of confidence that the BBFC’s work does. To take an example, the show American Dad is rated by the BBFC as Certificate 15 for reasons including ‘frequent crude sex references’, ‘strong violence’ and ‘drug misuse’. For Disney+, this content is appropriate for 12-year-olds to watch. The well-known Family Guy series is however rated 14+ despite the similarity in content.
Perhaps Disney might explain why something like Family Guy, a show which depicted a ‘flock’ of stereotyped Jewish clones obsessively picking up money, is put in the same category as the Mandalorian, a Star Wars spin off with great appeal to children? Why is American Dad supposedly more suitable for a younger audience than the latest in the Star Wars franchise?
The truth is that Disney has got it wrong, and parents might labour under the false pretence that content is suitable, when it would otherwise be judged inappropriate according to our national standards. After a while, parents and children alike will simply give up following the age-ratings on Disney+ because they do not make sense and cannot be trusted.
For many people, the invaluable detail accompanying the certificates provided by the BBFC on its website and elsewhere was crucial throughout the COVID-19 lockdowns, particularly as parents tried to assess the suitability of numerous films. Disney+ is falling short in this area too. There is a dearth of content advice on the platform. To use the same example, Family Guy employs crude and offensive stereotypes, including antisemitic stereotypes, as a form of humour. Contrary to British best practice, the Disney platform does not offer details about this or similar shows, despite taking steps to flag discriminatory content elsewhere on the platform. The result is a service on which it is more difficult to avoid the content you may not wish to see, and a platform that makes it more difficult to have informed conversations with young people about the content they are seeing.
In America and Australia Disney+ follows the various national film and TV ratings systems. For the whole of Europe, Disney is prepared to try its luck. By not adopting the BBFC national standard, it could be seen as Disney+ conducting a live experiment on our children. It will not only be any antisemitic content but any other racist and homophobic content which may be available on the platform to which this situation applies.
We bear all the risk, and the Disney company faces no cost. It is time for Disney+ to step up and meet our national standard, until then it is simply taking the mickey.
Catherine McKinnell MP is Co-Chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group Against Antisemitism