Become a Member
Alex Brummer

By

Alex Brummer,

Alex Brummer

Analysis

Harding’s battle for balance

April 18, 2013 13:50
1 min read

The re-emergence of James Harding, former editor of The Times, as the BBC's director of news, will be watched with interest in the Jewish community. He inherits a news culture that remains under siege and needs to re-establish the integrity that was badly damaged by the Jimmy Savile affair.

Given the scale of the task, it is hard to believe that the Middle-East will be top of the agenda. But he could go a long way towards demonstrating a new transparency by releasing the long-suppressed 2004 Balen report on coverage of Israel-Palestine.

As Times editor, Harding was fortunate enough to have, in proprietor Rupert Murdoch, a long-time supporter of Israel. At the BBC, he faces something very different. Even though coverage of the recent Pillar of Defence campaign in Gaza was more balanced - with quality air-time given to Israeli officials - sympathy with the Palestinian cause remains deeply embedded.

Much of the material on the BBC website relating to the Israel-Palestine issue is tendentious. The strained neutrality of the Beeb's Middle East editor Jeremy Bowen is not helpful either.