Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

As Jewish museum shooting trial concludes, one suspect argues he was ‘tricked’ by Iran or Lebanon

Belgian jury expected to deliver verdict on Thursday, at the end of Mehdi Nemmouche and Nacer Bendrer's seven-week trial

    Mehdi Nemmouche (left) in a court sketch. He faces a life sentence if convicted of the shooting at the Jewish Museum in Brussels in 2014
    Mehdi Nemmouche (left) in a court sketch. He faces a life sentence if convicted of the shooting at the Jewish Museum in Brussels in 2014 (Photo: Getty Images)

    The seven-week trial of the suspected Belgian Jewish museum killer ended on Tuesday with the suspect and his alleged accomplice denying any involvement.

    “I was set up,” said 33-year-old Mehdi Nemmouche in his final statement, without giving any explanation.

    The prosecution says 23 elements of evidence prove Mr Nemmouche is the man who killed four people in the Jewish museum in Brussels on May 24 2014.

    Security camera footage shows a man shooting Israeli tourists Miriam and Emmanuel Riva in the head as they were looking at brochures at the entrance.

    He then seen to proceed inside, killing 26-year-old Belgian museum employee Alexandre Strens and 66-year-old French volunteer Dominique Sabrier.

    The attack lasted just 84 seconds.

    Prosecutors said Mr Nemmouche’s DNA and fingerprints were found on the weapons, a handgun and a Kalashnikov, which he was carrying in a bag when he was arrested six days after the shooting.

    He had a laptop with an audio recording claiming responsibility for the attack.

    His alleged accomplice, Nacer Bendrer, testified that Mr Nemmouche asked him to supply weapons but Mr Bendrer said he did not deliver them.

    Mr Nemmouche was also identified by French journalists as one of the Isis fighters who detained and tortured them and Syrian hostages in 2013 in Syria.

    With the jury's verdict still to come, police officers stand guard in the Brussels court on Thursday
    With the jury's verdict still to come, police officers stand guard in the Brussels court on Thursday (Photo: Getty Images)

    But the defence said the evidence was ‘bogus” and “a comical sketch”, accusing police of fabricating evidence.

    During the trial’s seven weeks defence lawyers talked about a conspiracy insinuating Mossad was responsible for the atrocity.

    Mr Nemmouche’s lawyers said he was innocent because his fingerprints were not found on the museum’s entrance door. They argued the shooting was a conspiracy and the victims were killed because they had worked for Israeli intelligence.

    The Riva couple were “more than accountants,” they claimed.

    “Several months before the attack, they were in Berlin. This doesn’t mean they are criminals but that is where Mossad sends its agents in Europe,” said lawyer Sebastien Courtoy.

    In a closing argument that lasted seven hours, Mr Courtoy accused Shia Muslims working either for Iranian or Lebanese intelligence of setting his client up, but did not offer any evidence.

    He said these agencies recruited Nemmouche and then planted evidence to incriminate him.

    “I’m not going to hand out a photo-fit of those who did it,” Mr Courtoy said. “I don’t want to have an 80-second incident in my home,” he added, a reference to the museum attack’s 84-second duration.

    The jury was expected to deliver its verdict later on Thursday.

    Other lawyers involved in the trial said they were stunned by the defence team’s arguments.

    Mehdi Nemmouche's lawyer Sebastien Courtoy in court last month
    Mehdi Nemmouche's lawyer Sebastien Courtoy in court last month (Photo: Getty Images)

    “He talked for seven hours but didn’t say anything relevant to the case and the evidence,” Jewish associations lawyer Michèle Hirsch told the JC.

    “I guess his line of defence using conspiracy theories is in line with his client’s ideology of hatred.

    “But this trial was crucial because it showed Nemmouche was part of a terrorist network. He wasn’t a lone wolf but part of a pack of wolves.

    “Had he spoken about those who ordered the attack and other attacks committed later in Paris and Belgium, things could have turned differently.”

    Lawyers and prosecutors had never seen a defence like it, said Yohan Benizri from the Belgian Jewish umbrella group CCOJB.

    “Their arguments were unacceptable, ridiculous and completely baseless. We were also disappointed that the suspect refused to testify,” he said.

    “Of course they used this theory because their case is weak, so they chose to use fear and conspiracy theories.

    “But [we] want to show them we will not cave in or be deterred. Belgian institutions, Belgian Jews and the whole Belgian nation: we will show resilience.”

    Charged with four “terrorist assassinations”, Mr Nemmouche faces a life sentence if found guilty.

World

We will fight on, French Jewish murder victim’s brother vows

Shirli Sitbon

Monday, March 18, 2019

We will fight on, French Jewish murder victim’s brother vows
World

French Jewish murder victim's memorial vandalised

Shirli Sitbon

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

French Jewish murder victim's memorial vandalised
World

Hyper Cacher shooting suspect set to face charges

Shirli Sitbon

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

Hyper Cacher shooting suspect set to face charges
News Features

'They tried, and failed, to spread conspiracies'

Shirli Sitbon

Friday, March 15, 2019

'They tried, and failed, to spread conspiracies'
World

'I'm not afraid', French Jews say on siege anniversary

Shirli Sitbon

Wednesday, January 9, 2019

'I'm not afraid', French Jews say on siege anniversary
World

Le Pen praises French Holocaust denier

Shirli Sitbon

Monday, October 22, 2018

Le Pen praises French Holocaust denier
World

French Jews alarmed following surge in antisemitic incidents

Shirli Sitbon

Wednesday, February 13, 2019

French Jews alarmed following surge in antisemitic incidents
World

French politician acquitted over ‘armband’ tweet

Shirli Sitbon

Thursday, December 13, 2018

French politician acquitted over ‘armband’ tweet
World

France announces annual prize to combat hate in young people

Shirli Sitbon

Thursday, October 4, 2018

France announces annual prize to combat hate in young people