closeicon
News

Jewish Labour MP hits out at Jeremy Corbyn's antisemitism leaflet for saying Holocaust started in '1941'

Ruth Smeeth, JLM's parliamentary chair, says changes 'are not going to mean a thing if we can't even get the dates of the Holocaust right'

articlemain

Jewish Labour MP Ruth Smeeth has launched a furious attack on Jeremy Corbyn's bid to launch a fightback over the party's antisemitism crisis - accusing the leadership of bungling the dates of the Nazi Holocaust in campaign literature.

The Jewish Labour Movement's Parliamentary chair pointed to information in Labour's new guide to the roots of anti-Jewish racism - designed to tackle the problem within the party - which said the Holocaust took place "between 1941 and 1945."

Leaving the weekly Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) meeting on Monday evening, which was addressed by Mr Corbyn himself, Ms Smeeth fumed: "Changes to complaints and procedures are not going to mean a thing if we can't even get the dates of the Holocaust right in the literature.

"Who knew that 1941-1945 was when the Holocaust begun?"

Labour sources later tried to claim that the party's literature had used the "commonly understood academic timetable" of when the Shoah took place.

They accepted that others saw the rise to power of Hitler in 1933 as the real beginning of the Holocaust.

The Kristallnacht pogrom against Jews, which left at least 91 dead, took place in November 1938.

Ms Smeeth said she had been left incensed by Mr Corbyn's failure to answer the questions she had put to him at the meeting.

She raised the case of former Labour staffer Sam Matthews who had received a death threat from a pro-Corbyn activist after he appeared as a whistleblower on the BBC Panorama episode about Labour's racism crisis.

"Sam got a death threat and had to spend three hours with the Met Police on a Saturday night," she said.

"It went in one ear and out another," she said of Mr Corbyn's response. "I don't understand where humanity is meant to exist in our party if this is where we are.

"I read out a list of everything that had happened, not in the past three years, but in the past month.

"No comment, no reference, no awareness."

Earlier Labour had attempted to bolster muted response to an announcement, made on Monday ahead of a Shadow Cabinet meeting on the crisis, to move to allow the General Secretary, in company with the party's governing body, the National Executive Committee (NEC), to expel antisemites.

A later statement by the Shadow Cabinet announced further use of independent legal advice on decisions. It is understood deputy leader Tom Watson had left the meeting when this was issued.

But sources said he was encouraged by the announcement that independent advisers were being considered.

But it was unclear how the proposal, which is to be voted on at Tuesday's NEC meeting, would work.

Leaving the weekly PLP meeting, one MP said: "Same sh*t, different day."

Another said Mr Corbyn sounded like a "broken record".

But one Labour source said they believed their had been "some movement" with the Shadow Cabinet announcement.

Labour General Secretary Jennie Formby, who has recently been undergoing chemotherapy, addressed the PLP meeting at the start and was warmly applauded.

She had to be helped as she left by Mr Corbyn's Chief of Staff Karie Murphy.

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive