Politics
Pro-Palestine activists found guilty of harassing Labour MP have convictions overturned
The pair argued that their actions were protected under their right to free speech and expression
November 20, 2025 12:54
The pair argued that their actions were protected under their right to free speech and expression
November 20, 2025 12:54A pair of pro-Palestine activists who were found guilty in June of harassing Labour MP Alex Davies-Jones have had their convictions overturned on appeal.
Ayeshah Behit, 32, and Hiba Ahmed, 26, challenged the ruling, issued earlier this year by Cardiff Magistrates’ Court, on the grounds of their right to freedom of speech and expression.
The case related to the duo filming a confrontation with Davies-Jones, who represents Pontypridd, as she made her way to a campaign stop during the run-up to the 2024 General Election.
The clip saw Behit and Ahmed approach Davies-Jones, brandishing leaflets accusing the MP of being a “full-blown supporter of this genocide”, referring to the Gaza War.
"It was becoming quite scary,” said Davies-Jones, who described the pair as “confrontational”.
Francesca Cociani, for the appellants, argued: “It was not only in a public place but it was within her constituency... In the middle of a national campaign for the general election.”
Hearing the appeal at Cardiff Crown Court, Judge Tracey Lloyd-Clarke ruled that the convictions were unnecessary.
While she accepted that the appellants had put together a “planned and well-orchestrated campaign” to harm Davies-Jones’ chances in the election, she noted that “less intrusive” remedies, such as a police warning or civil action, were not pursued before a criminal conviction was sought.
"We are not satisfied that a prosecution was necessary... the appeals of both defendants are allowed,” she said.
However, the judge did add that “nothing in this judgment implies, or should be taken to imply, that there is any truth in the accusations made by the appellants about Ms Davies-Jones”.
To get more Politics news, click here to sign up for our free politics newsletter.