closeicon
News

My mother was a fantasist. Schindler’s List helped me understand who she really was

Max Friedman, the son of two Holocaust survivors, was reluctant to see Steven Spielberg’s film when it came out in 1993. But when he did, it changed his life

articlemain

When the film Schindler’s List was first released Max Friedman didn’t want to see it. His earliest memories are of hearing the words Mengele, Auschwitz and Amon Goeth, the SS officer played by Ralph Fiennes in the movie, which this year marks its 30th anniversary.

“Our mother told me and my sister from the very beginning of our lives about Mengele, about surviving his selection at Auschwitz. It felt like he lived with us.

"She’d also tell anyone who’d listen, people in the street, our postman, that she was a survivor. It embarrassed me and my sister beyond measure. It meant we tried very hard not to talk about those events.”

So when his wife and sons suggested he watch Steven Spielberg’s 1993 film about the German industrialist and Nazi party member Oskar Schindler who saved more than 1,000 Jews by employing them in his factories, Friedman, a retired writer, didn’t want to know. “But they urged me, pushed me, said it was about my mother’s past.”

The year after the film came out, Friedman gave in, watched it and discovered that his wife and sons had been right. His mother Frieda was not one of the Jews saved by Schindler, but her life mapped the film’s trajectory closely.

She had first been imprisoned in Krakow Ghetto, then in Plaszow labour camp just outside it, and had witnessed Goeth shoot Jews from the balcony of his villa. “My mother would tell us how you’d be standing next to someone, hear the crack of a rifle, and then see them to fall with a thud to the ground.”

For the next four years the film “sort of sat” in his head, he said. He didn’t try to find out any more about his mother’s past.

But when his mother died in 1998, finding out more suddenly felt urgent for the New Yorker, then 48. “I told my little grandson that his grandmother had been a Holocaust survivor and I felt ashamed that I couldn’t tell him much more, that the details I had about her life were so modest.

“It was the same story with my father, Szlama, also a survivor who had died five years earlier with Alzheimer’s, probably, I now know, caused by the beatings he suffered in concentration camps.

“Unlike my mother, he never talked about the Shoah, but I knew nothing about him either.

“All my sister and I really knew was that our parents were a mess, that as children we’d had to wake them up when they had nightmares, and that they fought with each other constantly, mostly about money.”

Determined to rectify this lack of knowledge about his parents, Friedman spent the next five years researching Frieda and Szlama’s lives in pre-war and wartime Poland.

His research led to the family memoir Painful Joy, published on Yom HaShoah in 2022, and took him from New York, where he’s spent most of his adult life, to Sweden, where his parents went after their liberation from Bergen-Belsen, and to Poland, where they were born.

“Everywhere in Poland where my father had lived had been raised to the ground. But when I found the building in Krakow’s historic Jewish quarter Kazmierz, where my mother and her family set up home in 1919 and where she lived after she married her first husband, I stopped dead in my tracks,” he said.

“It was called 12 Jozefa Street and not only was it still standing, but it was also the central location in Schindler’s List.”

What’s more, after the film came out, the building, now familiar to millions of viewers, assumed almost iconic status and became a must-visit destination on Shoah education trips to Poland.

In 2018, Friedman went to see 12 Jozefa Street for himself. The impact it had on him was profound.

“My mother was a fantasist who made up whole chunks of her life. I assume because she hadn’t lived the one she wanted to. She said her first husband had his own studio, but it wasn’t true.

She pretended she’d come from money, but she hadn’t. She used these stories to blame my father for not earning more, for not being more ambitious.

But the truth was her first husband, who had been murdered in Auschwitz, had made a very modest living making luggage and they were so poor she’d had to take in other people’s washing so they could eat.”

But she hadn’t fabricated 12 Jozefa Street and when Friedman saw the building for the first time, he sat on the steps outside it and watched Schindler’s List, for a second time, on his laptop. And he cried and cried and cried.

“Apart from Auschwitz it was the only place where I could be sure my mother had lived, somewhere that wasn’t a figment of her imagination. In a strange way, it was a place I could call home.”

Were he to meet Spielberg, he says he would thank him for “creating a film about the Holocaust to which a mass audience can relate, and that’s relatable to me in a very intimate way”.

And were she still with us, he says his mother would thank him too. “For all her losses and suffering, she’d have loved being able to say she’d lived in a building that had starred in a film.

“She thought she was beautiful and popular and a dancer, but in reality she was none of those things. But she did live at 12 Jozefa Street.”

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive