closeicon
News

Minister attacks 'naysayers' as inquiry into Westminster Holocaust Centre plans looms

A new report from the Tory-led Westminster Council confirmed its opposition to plans for the memorial by parliament

articlemain

LONDON, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 05: Housing Secretary Robert Jenrick arrives at 10 Downing Street for a cabinet meeting on November 5, 2019 in London, England. The UK’s main parties are gearing up for a December 12 general election after the motion was carried in a bid to break the current Parliamentary deadlock over Brexit. (Photo by Chris J Ratcliffe/Getty Images)

Communities Secretary Robert Jenrick has attacked the “naysayers” on the Westminster Holocaust Memorial project and insisted they “will not succeed” as a new report from the Tory-led Westminster Council’s planning committee confirmed their opposition to the plans.

Mr Jenrick revealed he and Lord Pickles, chair of the UK Holocaust Memorial Foundation, had met curators at Yad Vashem last month to discuss their involvement with the Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre being built in the Grade II listed Victoria Tower Gardens site next to Parliament.

“The naysayers on that project will not succeed,” said the minister. “We will build that memorial — let me promise you that.”

His comments came ahead of meeting of Westminster’s planning committee on Tuesday, whose report, which has been published, includes recommendations to oppose the “inappropriate development”.

The meeting is likely to see tensions over the project resurface along with a clash of opinion between the views of local Westminster Tories, who have opposed the project, and the government, which is wholeheartedly supporting it.

While agreeing with the principle of having a UK Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre, the council report says the project would harm “heritage assets” in the area.

It also warns of harm “bordering on substantial” to the trees in Victoria Tower Gardens.

The council no longer has the authority to determine the planning application for the Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre because it was “called in” by the Ministry of Housing Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) in November last year.

A final decision will be taken by the Secretary of State, following a public inquiry later this summer, at which Westminster’s views will be submitted.

But the JC has learned that the government’s decision to call in the project came amid growing frustrations with Westminster City Council under its previous leader Nickie Aitken, who became the MP for the seat in December’s election.

In a letter exchange released under Freedom of Information laws, former Tory minister Lord Eric Pickles and ex-Labour minister Ed Balls accused the council of giving “undue weight” to the number of objections on its planning portal.

They said their concerns were reinforced by “the number of antisemitic remarks that have been allowed to remain on the planning portal for far too long”.

Responding, Ms Aitken said she “profoundly refutes the very serious and wholly unfounded allegations about the operation of the planning service in the City of Westminster”.

She added: “As highly experienced national politicians, I am extremely disappointed with your irresponsible and frankly offensive assertions.”

The memorial was first proposed by former Prime Minister David Cameron on 27 January 2016, to mark Holocaust Memorial Day.

It has since received the backing of every living Prime Minister — including Sir John Major, Tony Blair, Gordon Brown — with former PM Theresa May pledging a further £25m towards the project last May.

But while Westminister Council’s Labour group has remained staunch in its support of the project, local Tory councillors have continued to raise objections.

One senior communal source told the JC that, while former leader Ms Aitken had shown “great understanding” over issues affecting the wider Jewish community, she had failed in her attempt to lead the local Tory group into a more positive stance over the Holocaust Memorial.

Another source added that Ms Aitken has “justifiably” become alarmed by repeated interventions by Lord Pickles over the project.

An MHCLG spokesperson said: “Following the call-in of the planning application for the United Kingdom Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre a public inquiry will be held and overseen by an independent planning inspector which will consider all available evidence.

"The inquiry is due in May.

“The final decision on the application will be made taking into account the inspector’s independent recommendation.”

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive