Become a Member
News

Labour candidate, whose band sang 'from the river to the sea', insists she believes in Israel's right to exist

Alana Bates played guitar in The Tribunes who sang: 'Justice should not have to wait, Israel is a racist state'

November 12, 2019 11:30
Alana Bates (left) played guitar in The Tribunes
1 min read
 
 

A Labour candidate has insisted she believes her band's song that includes the anti-Israel lyric "from the river to the sea" is not antisemitic.

Alana Bates, who is contesting the Conservative/Liberal Democrat marginal seat of St Ives in Cornwall, played guitar in a band called The Tribunes that performed a song that included the words "from the river to the sea" and said: "Justice should not have to wait, Israel’s an apartheid state, Justice should not have to wait, Israel is a racist state".

The chant "from the river to the sea" is a common refrain by anti-Israel campaigners who advocate the dismantling of the Jewish state. It has long been a Hamas rallying cry.

But Ms Bates told the Sun: "It’s not a political manifesto. I didn’t write it for a start. It’s a song.