Bishop cancels Jackie Walker's church hall meeting

Gathering in Edinburgh was "unacceptable" because it might have encouraged abuse, says senior clergyman


A talk by anti-Israel activist Jackie Walker in a church hall was called off on Monday following an intervention by the Bishop of Edinburgh.

Ms Walker, who is facing expulsion from the Labour Party over comments about Holocaust Memorial Day and antisemitism, had been scheduled to speak at a Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign event near to the city's castle.

But Episcopalian Bishop John Armes emailed the group to say he was cancelling the event, at St Columbia's hall, after gauging "wider implications" of staging a talk by the controversial activist.

Ms Walker, who once questioned the need for security at Jewish schools, later gave a speech outside the church in which she stated: "Let me reiterate, opposition to a Jewish state is and remains a legitimate honourable political position."

A banner held by two supporters as Ms Walker spoke read: "Antisemitism is a crime, Anti-Zionism is a duty."

Rt Rev Dr John Armes later issued a statement explaining his decision, saying: "We support freedom of speech; we also seek close and friendly relationships with people of every faith.

"On this occasion I considered that these two important values collided. I believe that the organisers of all political gatherings must take care to ensure that individuals and religious groups are not singled out for abuse because of their beliefs.

"My advice was that it would have been unacceptable for a gathering to take place in one of our churches that might encourage such abuse."

An email explaining the ban was also sent to the rector of St Columba's Scottish Episcopal Church, David Paton-Williams.

The rector said: “Criticism of Israel’s policies can have unintended consequences, leading to an increase in antisemitic attacks."

He added: "I have been in consultation with the bishop, to gauge the wider implications of the event, and to ask his advice. 

"Having talked it over with him, I am writing to let you know that St Columba's is cancelling the booking for Monday night's meeting. I do not do this lightly and I regret that it is at this short notice."

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive