The filmmaker’s debut is as Jewish as can be and a wonderful evocation of New York
September 15, 2025 13:53
In November, Woody Allen celebrates his 90th birthday. Of course, he is best known as a wonderful stand-up comic, screenwriter and film director in a career stretching back to the 1950s and including masterpieces like Annie Hall, Manhattan and Crimes and Misdemeanors. He has also written a number of books including two brilliant collections of short stories, Getting Even and Without Feathers, both published in the 1970s.
Now, amazingly, he has published his first novel, What’s with Baum? Asher Baum is 51, a middle-aged Jewish writer. He started out as a successful journalist and has tried – unsuccessfully – to become a novelist. Everyone, his wife, his stepson, his agent and his publisher, think he’s a failure. Even Baum admits, “I have not lived up to my potential.”
Baum also suffers from panic attacks and has begun talking to himself, obsessively and increasingly loudly. People stare at him. They walk into the toilet, hear him talking to himself and walk straight out again. “You were crying, he tells himself, because nothing works. … your life, your work, your marriage. … Everything’s unraveling.” His stepson tells Baum’s wife, “He’s a loser, Mother.”
Baum is married for the third time and this marriage is his worst. Connie is attractive but deeply unpleasant and completely obsessed with her son, Thane. Baum is convinced that Connie has had an affair with his brother Josh. As for Thane, he is as unpleasant as his mother and is about to publish his first novel. Unfortunately for Baum, Thane unlike his stepfather looks set for a brilliant literary career. There’s already a buzz about his novel and there are plans for a TV documentary about him to be made by an acclaimed director. Baum can’t stand his stepson, and the feelings are mutual. To make things even worse, Baum loves New York but has followed Connie to her grand house in the country. Needless to say, like any Woody Allen character, he can’t stand the countryside and pines for the big city.
The novel is peppered with the names of well-known Jewish magazines and writers like Bellow, Roth and Hannah Arendt
Baum is his own worst enemy. At times he is impossible. And there is one awkward plotline when Baum is accused to harassing a female journalist which he denies, albeit unconvincingly. This obviously brings up disturbing associations with the sexual abuse allegations brought against Allen in 1992 by his then wife Mia Farrow who accused him of molesting their adoptive daughter. The allegations were investigated and dismissed, but the controversy had a huge impact on Allen’s film career, with many people in Hollywood refusing to work with him.
And yet there is something very sympathetic about him. It’s partly his Jewishness. What’s with Baum? is Jewish as can be. It is full of Yiddish expressions and references to famous New York Jewish eating places like Barney Greengrass. Baum and one of his closest friends, Amnon Weinstock, meet up every year “to continue their disputations over blintzes at an Upper West Side dairy restaurant.” The novel is peppered with the names of well-known Jewish magazines and writers like Bellow, Roth and Hannah Arendt. Baum’s grandfather was a German-Jewish refugee and there are numerous references to the Holocaust.
But, above all, Baum is decent and deserves his big break. Will it come? The novel gathers pace and intensity and eventually Baum (and the reader) are rewarded with a thrilling twist. Woody Allen’s first novel is worth the wait. It’s a delightful read and at its best it’s one of the best evocations of New York you could wish for, a reminder of Allen’s past glories as a filmmaker. All the same, it is for these films that he will always be remembered.
What’s with Baum?
By Woody Allen
Swift Press
To get more from Life, click here to sign up for our free Life newsletter.