Joni Reiner gave Modiin a two-goal cushion with a great strike, but England stepped up a gear and pulled one back.
Modiin responded well and a clinical finish from new boy Yonatan Journo, their second new signing from Athletico, gave them a 3-1 lead at half-time.
England moved the ball around well at the start of the second half, but it was Modiin who were to score next, with Matan Kroizer's cross from the left met on the volley by Reiner
Modiin continued to push and a great 1-2 ended with Kroizer converting majestically to make it 5-1.
Further strikes from Adi Meiyuri and Beni Sragif - the youngest player on the pitch - completed the rout in a contest where England lost their heads in the last 25 minutes, with two more red cards leaving them with eight men.