The original tie in Liverpool on Sunday finished 1-1 after 90 minutes. Match referee Ray McLaughlin then informed both captains he could only play 10 minutes each way of extra-time, rather than the official 15 as he had another engagement.
With no further goals, the tie was settled by penalties, with Haroldeans progressing 2-1. Or so they thought.
However, on Tuesday, National Football Committee chief Rob Richman, who runs the Peter Morrison Trophy, confirmed the referee's timekeeping had contravened one of the competition's rules.
A statement from the competition organiser read: "The management committee received a complaint from Manchester Maccabi regarding the amount of extra-time played in the cup quarter-final versus Haroldeans.