Life & Culture

The Curse of Pietro Houdini, review: Riveting wartime art-heist tale plus philosophy

This is a sweeping work of storytelling bravado


He looked me over, assessed my wristwatch, considered my shoes and the likely cost of my hairdo, and tried to decide if I came from a family worth talking to; such is Italy.”

In one crisp sentence, Derek B Miller plunges the reader into a riveting mystery set against one of the greatest and most important battles of the Second World War, Montecassino. At the centre is the friendship between an older man, Pietro Houdini, who has a mysterious past, and the central protagonist, 14-year-old Massimo. The pair first encounter each other in the aftermath of the Nazi bombing of Rome in 1943, and Pietro takes Massimo to the towering building that is the monastery of Monte Cassino, where they find initial shelter among the monks.

But – as with every Miller novel; he also wrote the award- winning Norwegian by Night – all is not as it seems. The monastery, hundreds of years old, has become the repository of centuries’ worth of priceless art. And that being the case, the Nazis focus on the art collection which they are determined to loot. Pietro, however, is just as determined to salvage some of the artworks.

Together with Massimo and an unlikely cast of random characters — plus Ferrari, a heroic mule — Pietro Houdini leads a ragtag band out of the monastery as the Allies, led by the Americans, bomb and assault the abbey in their effort to destroy the Nazis who now occupy it.

Houdini is not, of course, the wily Pietro’s real name, but one he has adopted in part homage to the world-famous escape artist. We do discover his real identity eventually — and Massimo also undergoes an identity change.

Montecassino was a famous, or perhaps that should be infamous, battle towards the end of the war, frequently referenced by American veterans, but not necessarily with the same resonance in Britain. It resulted in the destruction of the monastery, which was rebuilt after the war. Many of the artworks stolen by the Nazis – and removed from the monastery in a meticulous German operation in February 1944, with the promise that they would be stored in the Vatican – were recovered by the American Monuments Men in July 1945, hidden in a salt mine, 70 kilometres from Salzburg.

Miller, in this novel, has tried to answer the “what if” question about art which was not recovered. He has forensically re-created both the wholesale Nazi theft and the terror experienced by ordinary Italian citizens, (including Jews) as the Allies pounded the area. And along the way we get a healthy dose of philosophy, resilience and survival techniques. We also discover, of course, exactly what was Pietro Houdini’s curse.

The Curse of Pietro Houdini

by Derek B Miller

Doubleday, £20

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive