Become a Member
Judaism

Love poetry shouldn't be on the forbidden list

Orthodox schoolchildren ought to be equipped to tackle poems about romance in exams

June 25, 2015 12:34
Romancing the bard: the balcony scene from Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet

By

Rabbi Ariel Abel,

Rabbi Ariel Abel

3 min read

When poems about falling in love appeared in a GCSE English exam this year , a number of Orthodox schools were unhappy. They felt their students were at a disadvantage because the subject was outside their cultural and social experience.

When I was a student at a strictly Orthodox, male-only grammar school in North Manchester, literature was censored by the headmaster's wife; she read books ahead of time for both our school and the girls' school. I am very grateful to her, as I doubt that the book we studied for A-level English Literature by Thomas Keneally, Schindler's List, would
pass muster in the same school 25 years later; it contains a rather vivid description of Oskar Schindler sharing a bathtub with a female SS officer.

I recall the effect this had on us as religiously observant teenagers. Suddenly we were able to appreciate that righteous gentiles who risked their lives to save Jews in Nazi Europe had a carnal and hedonistic side to them. Oskar Schindler, immortalised in Steven Spielberg's three-hour epic film, first came to life for us between the leaves of a paperback, and symbolises the struggle of human saviours, not unlike the biblical Queen Esther who slept with the enemy to save her people.

Last week the controversial GCSEs sparked a Facebook exchange on how the religious sector shelters young members of its communities from all talk of love between the sexes. Although I grew up in a very religious community, my teachers and mentors did not refrain from addressing these topics. My father is well-known among his many students for never dropping a single Rashi from the school syllabus.

To get more from judaism, click here to sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Editor’s picks