Family & Education

Ofsted head denies targeting Jewish schools

Chief inspector Amanda Spielman says Ofsted knows some Orthodox schools have problems with aspects of equality law


Amanda Spielman, the chief inspector of Ofsted, has rejected suggestions it has disproportionately targeted Jewish schools.

At a hearing at the House of Commons education committee last week, Ian Mearns, the MP for Gateshead, who has several Charedi independent schools in his constituency, said it seemed Ofsted visited Orthodox schools “much more” than others.

But Mrs Spielman responded: “I don’t think that this is the case”.

She explained some schools might receive more frequent visits if they had been categorised as inadequate – the lowest inspection grade.

During an hour and a half appearance, she was repeatedly questioned by MPs over the inspection service’s policy towards faith institutions.

She said she had never been allied with “any secularist cause” and explained that remarks she had made in a recent speech about the need for “muscular liberalism” in schools were not about advocating secularism.

They were about “making sure we don’t inadvertently create spaces where intolerance can breed”, she said.

Mrs Spielman acknowledged some Orthodox Jewish schools had “a problem” with aspects of equality law.

According to independent school guidelines, schools must teach British values of respect and tolerance towards others, paying “regard” to groups protected under equality law  - which include transgender people or those of same-sex orientation.

She told MPs she had been asked on occasions to “disapply” the law in this area when inspecting schools in order to respect parental wishes.

 “This is a difficult one for Ofsted because we have no ability to selectively disapply the law in inspection. We have to work with the law as it stands,” she said.

Contrasting educational standards between independent and state schools, she said Muslim and Jewish state schools by and large performed “extremely well”.

The Ofsted head renewed her call for greater powers to scrutinise unregulated faith educational institutions (which include a number of  yeshivot).

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive