Become a Member
Opinion

The trashing of Jonathan Sacks is a trashing of all Jews

On antisemitism, Lord Sacks speaks for all but a tiny minority of Jews, says David Hirsh

August 29, 2018 19:09
Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, pictured in 2016
1 min read

I feel that there's something humiliating for all Jews about the trashing of Rabbi Sacks.

I thought of starting with some left-cred throat-clearing about ways in which I'm critical of him. But I'm done with that nowadays.

On the issue of Corbyn and antisemitism he speaks for Jews; except for the tiny minority who are prepared, under antisemitic duress, to declare their disavowal of Israel and Zionism and hence escape the hostile and external designation of "Zionist" - meaning racist, pro-apartheid etc.

Some will say that he exaggerated a bit and others will say he wasn't tactically astute. Actually I don't agree with either of these criticisms but, I don't think they matter. If he had expressed himself more conservatively it would have changed nothing.

To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.

Editor’s picks