Become a Member
Opinion

The Mythical Distinction

March 18, 2010 16:35
3 min read

There is a direct link between the way Israel's case is presented in the media and anti-semitism - statement of fact.
Read the Guardian, look at the BBC web site, watch Press TV and Al Jazeera etc etc.
Behind criticism of Israel there is a more sinister agenda, that of anti-semitism. Those Jews who defend Israel are then depicted by their critics as seeking an excuse to justify Israel, projecting Jewish paranoia and displaying a "typical" Jewish trait of "sticking together", listen to the rantings of George Galloway, Jeremy Corbyn, Vanessa Redgrave, Glenda Jackson, Ken Livingstone - the list goes on.

It is obvious to a blindman that anti-semitism today is linked to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict; what have attacks on Jewish property and persons in the UK got to do with Israeli policies vs the Palestinians? Just that we are Jewish and Israel is the Jewish State.

The anal, "trend-lefty", 2-digit IQ debate tahat there is a distinction between anti-semitism and anti-Zionism -misses the crucial point of contention. Israel's advocates do not want to gag critics by brandishing the bogeyman of anti-semitism: rather, they are concerned about the form the criticism takes.

If Israel's critics are truly opposed to anti-semitism, they should not repeat traditional anti-semitic themes under the anti-Israel banner. When such themes - the Jewish conspiracy to rule the world, linking Jews with money and media, the hooked-nose stingy Jew, those anti-Sharon bay eating cartoons, the blood libel, disparaging use of Jewish symbols, or traditional Christian anti-Jewish imagery - are used to describe Israel's actions, concern should be voiced.
Ex-Labour MP Tam Dalyell decried the influence of "a Jewish cabal" on British foreign policy-making; an Italian cartoonist depicted the Israeli siege of the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem as an attempt to kill Jesus "again". Is it necessary to evoke the Jewish conspiracy or depict Israelis as Christ-killers to denounce Israeli policies?