Opinion

The conditional Jew: when acceptance depends on first denouncing Israel

The contemporary loyalty test speaks the language of justice, solidarity and inclusion, and is no less discriminatory for doing so

November 19, 2026 16:32
Rodan.jpg
La France Insoumise (LFI) candidate in France's 2027 presidential election Jean-Luc Melenchon on November 7, 2026. (Image: Getty Images)

The acceptable Jew of our time is not required to convert. He is required to issue a statement.

This summer, my friend Yedidia Levy-Zauberman booked a sailing boat in Greece for himself and his family. Before embarking, the skipper sent him a WhatsApp message. The manager had identified Levy-Zauberman as being Jewish, he explained, and therefore needed to know whether he supported the “occupation in Gaza”. The message came with an apology and an embarrassed emoji.

The family was shell-shocked. Could a Jewish name really be enough, today, to subject someone to such crass discrimination?

The experience is far from unique. Earlier this year, Rabbi Yoni Birnbaum of Finchley United Synagogue sought to book a holiday home in France. After discovering from his email address that he was a rabbi, the owners asked him to confirm that he belonged to a “progressive, liberal Jewish movement” and condemned the actions of the Israeli government and army. Otherwise, they explained, they could not accommodate his family.

To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.

Topics:

Israel

Support the world’s oldest Jewish newspaper