By

Rabbi Aaron Goldstein

Opinion

Organ Donation: The Government should not need to legislate

July 14, 2013 01:08

The words from our Torah portion this morning at face value (the peshat) begins the recollection of the Israelites wanderings in the Wilderness. Yet there are notable differences in the words attributed to Moses although undoubtedly written many years later in the times of King Josiah circa. 621 BCE. They highlight that these passages are unconcerned with historical accuracy. Rather, their import is found through the exegetical tool of remez, seeking the message alluded to by the deliberate misquoting of history: literally seeking the moral or f the story.

Moses is cast as the moralizing historian, recounting history in such a way as to emphasise the Deuteronomic point. Specifically, Moses recalls that the Israelites were given the opportunity to conquer the Land but out of lack of faith in God had shied away from doing so. Moses does not mention the report of the 10 spies who suggested that the Land and those dwelling in it would be hard to conquer. He only mentions the good reports of Caleb and Joshua leaving the words of the 10 others to be uttered from the mouths of the People. Moses concludes that because of their lack of faith in God’s power to save, the whole generation was doomed to wandering about and ultimately death in the Wilderness.

The language is highly emotive:

Uvamidbar asher ra-ita asher nsa-akha Adonai Eloheikha ka’sher yisa ish et b’no b’khol haderekh asher halakhtem, ad boakhem ad ha’makom ha’zeh.

To get more from opinion, click here to sign up for our free Editor's Picks newsletter.

Support the world’s oldest Jewish newspaper