Become a Member
Film

The Edge Of Love

June 20, 2008 13:19

By

Gerald Aaron

1 min read

https://api.thejc.atexcloud.io/image-service/alias/contentid/173pqfw8xw2pmksaz7z/star_two.GIF?f=3x2&w=732&q=0.6 (15)

I thought Keira Knightley’s finest performance was her compelling portrait of a troubled waitress in director John Maybury’s barely-seen fantasy thriller The Jacket — much better than her work in the much-praised hit Atonement.

This Second World War-set melodrama reunites The Jacket star and director, but it has none of the earlier film’s spark. The Edge of Love centres on Welsh poet Dylan Thomas (Matthew Rhys) and his love for two women — his wife Caitlin (Sienna Miller) and sometime lover Vera (Knightley). Maybury lays on period detail with a steam shovel, decorating it and the drama with artistic flourishes which look good but add nothing to the uneven narrative.

https://api.thejc.atexcloud.io/image-service/alias/contentid/173prtg8jpoghrt1ztp/The%2520edge%2520of%2520love.landscape.jpg%3Ff%3Ddefault%26%24p%24f%3D0d0c04e?f=3x2&w=732&q=0.6
Kiera Knightley (left) flashes her tooth-filed grin but gets out-acted by Sienna Miller

And, far too often, Knightley returns to relying on her trademark tooth-filled grin rather than creating and illuminating her character. Even hampered by a less than persuasive screenplay, many of the dramatic scenes are beyond her capabilities.

To get more from Life, click here to sign up for our free Life newsletter.