closeicon

David Rose

Enjoy this pro-Israel government while it lasts

This administration looks doomed and Labour’s policies on the Jewish state are untested

articlemain

BIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 02: Delegates attend on the first day of the Conservative Party conference at Birmingham ICC on October 02, 2022 in Birmingham, England. This year the Conservative Party Conference will be looking at "Getting Britain Moving" with more jobs and higher salaries. However, delegates are arriving at the conference as the party lags 33 points behind Labour in the opinion polls. (Photo by Ian Forsyth/Getty Images)

October 04, 2022 15:31

IT is hard to imagine any British government better disposed towards Jews and Israel than this one. But on the evidence of the Conservative Party conference in Birmingham, there may not be much time to enjoy it.

The party’s commitment to fighting antisemitism and fostering the warmest relationship with the Jewish state is enormous. No fewer than seven Cabinet ministers, led by the PM, made speeches at a Conservative Friends of Israel (CfI) reception on Sunday night. Several, Ms Truss included, repeated her pledge to review moving the British embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem; junior minister Robert Jenrick revealed that a UK-owned site in Jerusalem, understood to be in Talpiot, had already been earmarked.

But even before Kwasi Kwarteng’s tax U-turn, the gloom enshrouding the event was palpable.

At the start of the week, one former Cabinet minister told me: “A lot of MPs have been phoning me up and I give them all the same message: get ready for opposition.” Another revealed: “The debate among senior backbenchers is whether we’re facing a mere electoral disaster or a catastrophe. We lost control of events last week and that is something you cannot afford to do.”

The lack of coordination was evident in other areas of policy, including the embassy move. A few hours before the CfI reception, a senior Foreign Office aide suggested that Ms Truss’s commitment to her “review” might be liable to revision. This was wrong, but the Foreign Secretary and Prime Minister did not seem to be on the same page.

A few days earlier, the Labour Party in Liverpool had looked and sounded like a government in waiting: disciplined and energetic. There seemed to be at least twice as many present at the Labour Friends of Israel reception as there were at CfI’s.

Thanks to the unfortunate fact that Ms Truss is to make her keynote speech on Yom Kippur, I write this on Tuesday morning, the day before her only chance to save her government. Maybe, by the time you read this, she will have pulled off something dazzling. But the prospects do not look good.

Take Mr Kwarteng. He not only took a PhD from Cambridge but won University Challenge and has written well-regarded books. Yet whatever one thinks of the economic logic of cutting the 45 per cent tax rate during a cost-of-living crisis, he seems not to have noticed that this would be a political gift to Labour, which Sir Keir Starmer has seized.

Then came the U-turn. When Mr Kwarteng spoke on Monday, the auditorium was, for once, full. But the Chancellor made just two flippant references to the change of direction, meaning much of the market turmoil of the preceding weeks — “a little turbulence” — had been for nothing.

“We listened, we get it,” he said. To which the party area chairman sitting next to me barked: “Oh no you don’t!”

Until well past midnight, I sat in the main conference hotel bar. It was a heaving hubbub of besuited politicians, special advisers, NGO lobbyists and Tory members that spilled out 20 people deep onto the concourse in front of the building.

Some were still in denial. One Surrey councillor was hunting for ITN political editor Robert Peston so she could scold him for his “biased”, downbeat coverage. A general election victory was still within the Tories’ grasp, she insisted, and Liz Truss was proving herself to be an outstanding PM. But she was something of an outlier.

“Enjoy it while you can,” one young parliamentary aide told me. “This may be the last time the party meets while still in power. We’re f***ed.” It was a phrase I heard time and again.

Sometimes, poll leads such as the 20-30 per cent that Labour has opened up do evaporate.

After all, the Tories polled just nine per cent nationally in the Euro elections of 2019, months before Boris Johnson scored his landslide.

But those with longer memories — including another former Cabinet member who now sits in the Lords — recalled that Mr Kwarteng’s attempt to laugh off his U-turn echoed John Major’s after Black Wednesday. After that, a floating pound and sound economic management saw Britain begin a golden era of low-inflation growth. But Tony Blair still won a landslide at the next election, five years later.

Ms Truss must go to the polls in just over two years. “Do you think they will move the embassy before the next election?” a senior Israeli diplomat asked me, plaintively. The assumption was obvious. Despite his genuine commitment to fighting antisemitism, the chances of Sir Keir opening an embassy in Jerusalem can be calculated as precisely zero.

October 04, 2022 15:31

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive