Judaism

Why Liberals brought back barmitzvahs

Modern Progresssives have restored traditions their radical forebears discarded

February 3, 2011 14:08
Reinterpreting tradition at the Liberal Jewish Synagogue, St John’s Wood, which celebrates its centenary this year

By

Rabbi Alexandra Wright

3 min read

My grandmother, born in 1906, was 16 when she began attending services at The Liberal Jewish Synagogue, founded in 1911 and celebrating the momentous milestone of its centenary this year. Established by men and women drawn from the spectrum of Anglo-Jewry, the LJS has, in many ways, been in the vanguard of religious and social change during the century of its existence.

What drew my grandmother initially to the new synagogue was the dynamic and charismatic rabbi, Dr Israel Mattuck, who impressed all who heard him expound Liberal Judaism, with its emphasis on ethical conduct and informed conscience.

But a century after Mattuck had led the way in providing a form of worship that combined the spiritual and moral values of Judaism with the religious needs of his congregation, extended Jewish education for boys and girls until confirmation (later Kabbalat Torah) at 16, rejecting barmitzvah for boys at 13, where does the LJS now stand on the religious spectrum? How faithful has it been to the principles of its founders and how has it managed what seems like a reversion to some of the traditions originally abolished?

What would its early members make of the increased use of Hebrew in the services and a return to the traditional structure of the liturgy in its prayer books of the last 50 years? How would they have reacted to the pressure from members to introduce bar- and batmitzvah in 1981 or the more recent practice of both boys and girls to leyn from the Torah? How would they have regarded the wearing of kippot by the majority of the male members of the congregation and some of the women, a practice that Mattuck had declared optional soon after his arrival, or the voluntary undertaking of mikveh for converts?

To get more from judaism, click here to sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Support the world’s oldest Jewish newspaper