Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Macron 'ashamed' by police advice for Jewish families to move away

Community leader says some Jews were given the advice after receiving antisemitic threats

    Emmanuel Macron addressing Crif last week
    Emmanuel Macron addressing Crif last week (Photo: Crif)

    Growing insecurity and online antisemitism were at the heart of French President Emmanuel Macron’s first Crif dinner, an annual gala organised by France’s Jewish umbrella group.

    Gathered last week in the same hall in the Louvre where Mr Macron made his election victory speech last May, the president and Jewish leaders talked about the plight of Jews who have had to leave neighbourhoods where antisemitism is on the rise.

    French authorities registered 311 antisemitic threats and attacks in 2017, with the number of violent aggressions up by 26 per cent compared with the previous year.

    “It’s high time for the state to restore its authority,” said Francis Kalifat, who leads Crif.

    “People who had been threatened told me that police advised them to move away because ‘they have been detected’.

    “Something is wrong when people have no other option but to leave.”

    In his remarks, Mr Macron referred directly to the police message.

    “I’m ashamed if people have been given that kind of advice,” he said.

    “It’s not a republic if some neighbourhoods are reserved for some and banned for others.”

    “I heard of children who have had to leave their public school and enrol in a private school. Children of all faiths and all backgrounds should be able to attend public schools.” 

    He continued: “France is not abandoning Jewish families. No attack or threat will be tolerated. I will fight on all levels: in schools, with other countries, on an international level.”

    Emmanuel Macron said French authorities are working on a new pan-European plan with the UK to tackle antisemitism and racism online.

    “We were inspired by a German law. We are hoping for a legal framework that would force social networks to [detect] antisemitic messages within a day’s time.”

    A French government body set up to coordinate actions against antisemitism and racism, Dilcra, is due to present a new biannual plan focusing on web-based hate later this month.

    Jerusalem was another topic debated in the evening, with Mr Kalifat urging the president to follow Donald Trump’s Jerusalem move because “Jerusalem has been Israel’s capital for 3,000 years.”

    But Mr Macron did not signal a change in French policy: “My friend Donald Trump – we always say we’re friends before stating our differences – he decided to recognise Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and I think that did not improve security in the region.”

    “If France followed his lead, we would lose our ‘honest broker’ status. And that status is the most useful thing we have. If we lost it, that would be bad for everyone, including Israel.”

    Mr Macron also said he would not intervene in a recent controversy in France over the decision to reprint antisemitic pamphlets written before the Second World War by the novelist Louis-Ferdinand Céline.

    Crif lobbied against the documents’ republication.

     “There is no historic moral police in France that would allow me to tell an editor ‘you can’t print this’.” Mr Macron said.

    To applause from the crowd, he added: “But you know how I personally feel about this issue.”

Analysis

France rocked by yet another antisemitic murder

Shirli Sitbon

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

France rocked by yet another antisemitic murder
World

New Unesco chief must ‘restore honour’, Israel says

Shirli Sitbon

Friday, October 20, 2017

New Unesco chief must ‘restore honour’, Israel says
World

French Interior Minister condemns Paris hacksaw attack

Shirli Sitbon

Wednesday, March 1, 2017

French Interior Minister condemns Paris hacksaw attack
World

Hundreds mark Paris supermarket siege anniversary

Shirli Sitbon

Wednesday, January 10, 2018

Hundreds mark Paris supermarket siege anniversary
World

Kosher market bombers go to trial in Paris

Shirli Sitbon

Monday, April 24, 2017

Kosher market bombers go to trial in Paris
Israel

Israel has still not left Unesco

Shirli Sitbon

Friday, November 10, 2017

Israel has still not left Unesco
World

French Jewish historian Bensoussan cleared of hate speech

Shirli Sitbon

Thursday, March 9, 2017

French Jewish historian Bensoussan cleared of hate speech