Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Did Al Jazeera host really praise IDF?

    An episode of The Opposite Direction, Al-Jazeera’s flagship live discussion programme, caught the attention of Western commentators this week for apparently backing Israel’s military tactics over those used by Syrian armies.

    Faisal Al-Qaseem, the channel’s star journalist, contrasted the Jewish state’s “humanity” in trying to avoid civilian casualties during armed conflict to the indiscriminate bombardment of civilians by the Syrians.

    “Why don’t [the Syrians] learn from the Israeli army, which tries, through great efforts, to avoid shelling areas populated by civilians in Lebanon and Palestine?” he asked.

    Colonial French rule in Syria in the first half of the 20th century, he continued, can be compared to Israel’s treatment of its opponents.

    “Neither the Israelis nor the French killed their people,” he claimed, before demanding of a guest: “Please tell me how many of their people did the French army kill.”

    Impressed, veteran Middle East correspondent Tom Gross asked when Western news outlets “will be as honest” as Mr Al-Qaseem.

    But context is all.

    Al-Jazeera is funded and editorially controlled by the Emir of Qatar, the financial backer of the Muslim Brotherhood and large contingents of jihadis in Syria.

    So crude has the station’s anti-Assad propaganda become in recent years that dozens of its staff, despite being largely made up of Brotherhood supporters, have resigned in disgust.

    By praising Israel, Mr Al-Qaseem’s motive, one suspects, was to denigrate the Syrian regime by comparing it unfavourably even to hated Israel. After all, last year, Al-Jazeera aired a call by its resident quack, Youseff Al-Qaradawi, for genocide against the Shia — on the basis that they are “even more infidel” than the Jews.

    That Mr Al-Qaseem was dancing to his paymaster’s tune is obvious from his history of anti-Israeli rhetoric. On the same programme in 2004, he offered a largely glowing assessment of Osama bin Laden, but faulted his failure to attack Israel. “Where is his struggle, his jihad against Israel? Why are we not seeing it?”, he asked.

    Seeing through Mr Al-Qaseem’s shenanigans should have been easy, especially given his comments on the “benign” French occupation.

    During the 1925 Syrian revolt alone, French troops killed an estimated 6,000 rebels, hung mutilated corpses in squares throughout Syria and displaced over 100,000 civilians.

    The population of Syria at the time was 3 million compared to 23 million today, meaning that the French were, if anything, proportionately at least as murderous as the Assad regime

    Do we really want to champion such a comparison with Israel? Instead, we should perhaps reflect on how the enemy’s enemy is not always a friend.

    John R Bradley is the author of four books on the Middle East

UK News

Priti Patel criticised for ‘secret’ Israel meetings

Rosa Doherty

Friday, November 3, 2017

Priti Patel criticised for ‘secret’ Israel meetings
World

Rabbi among Mexico quake victims

Daniel Sugarman

Monday, September 25, 2017

Rabbi among Mexico quake victims
Comment

Settlement expansion is first step in new era

Anshel Pfeffer

Thursday, January 26, 2017

Settlement expansion is first step in new era
Analysis

Israel concern that centenary is being downplay...

Anshel Pfeffer

Thursday, November 2, 2017

Israel concern that centenary is being downplay...
Israel

Concerns raised about Israel's anti-boycott law

Orlando Radice

Thursday, March 9, 2017

Concerns raised about Israel's anti-boycott law
World

Netanyahu invited to meet Abbas in Paris

Rosa Doherty

Wednesday, December 7, 2016

Netanyahu invited to meet Abbas in Paris
World

Anthony Weiner jailed for 21 months

Michael Daventry

Monday, September 25, 2017

Anthony Weiner jailed for 21 months
World

Trump to crackdown on Iran and its "terrorist minions", says Pence

JC Reporter

Sunday, February 26, 2017

Trump to crackdown on Iran and its "terrorist minions", says Pence
World

'Jews should pay for their own security' say Swiss

Daniel Sugarman

Sunday, December 4, 2016

'Jews should pay for their own security' say Swiss