Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

'Zionist myth' book on prize shortlist

    A controversial book which argues that the idea of a Jewish people descended from the ancient Israelites is a Zionist myth, has been shortlisted for British Jewry's main literary award.

    The Invention of the Jewish People by Tel Aviv University Professor Shlomo Sand is one of four books up for the Jewish Quarterly-Wingate Literary Prize.

    But the choice has already come under fire. Mark Gardner, the communications director for the Community Security Trust, who has previously attacked the book, said this week: "The accuracy and originality of this book have been challenged by serious critics, including Anita Shapiro of the Journal of Israeli History, whose review was entitled The Jewish-people deniers. This properly summarises the book's attack upon our notions of Jewish heritage, history and peoplehood.

    "Sand's logic is directed against modern Israel, but it subverts Jews everywhere, reducing them to little more than a random assortment who happen to share a religion."

    Alan Mendoza, director of the Israel-Diaspora Trust, said: "The cultural, historical and religious roots of the Jewish people are self-evident and Sands' desire for self-immolation is not shared by Anglo-Jewry. Was this decision motivated by intellectual navel-gazing of the most banal kind, or does it reflect an attempt to appease those viscerally anti-Israel elements within the broader liberal intelligentsia? Either way, this is a pathetic attempt at gesture politics, and one that cheapens the Wingate Prize."

    The four judges were chaired by the broadcaster Anne Karpf, a founding member of Independent Jewish Voices, formed to promote alternative views of Israel. Another was musician Joseph Finlay, who has been involved with the alternative cultural group, Jewdas.

    Ms Karpf did not want to comment on the shortlist before the June prizegiving, adding: "I don't want to jump the gun."

    Prof Sand's book disputes that there was a mass exodus of Jews from Palestine in Roman times and suggests that many are descended from converts.

    The idea of a Jewish nation based on a common ethnic origin emerged among 19th century Jewish historians, he argues. It was used by Zionists to make the case for a Jewish homeland.

    In a review for the FT, the historian Simon Schama said the book "fails to sever the remembered connection between the ancestral land and the Jewish experience ever since" and he attacked Prof Sand's "many… twists of historical logic and strategic evasions of modern research".

    Masorti senior rabbi Jonathan Wittenberg, wrote in the Guardian that the book was "marred by tendentious premises, the misreading of key events and the ignoring of central texts".

    In the JC, reviewer Rabbi David Goldberg described the book as "overblown, learned, occasionally brilliant and always polemical".

    But one Wingate judge, Naomi Gryn, said she was "unhappy that the book was on the shortlist", adding: "I bowed to the democratic process. I thought the arguments he used to support his thesis were spurious."

Uk News

Government drops pledge to aid 3,000 child refugees

Rosa Doherty

Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Government drops pledge to aid 3,000 child refugees
Uk News

Limmud: Food for thought at session on 'ethical eating'

By Simon Rocker

Tuesday, December 27, 2016

Limmud: Food for thought at session on 'ethical eating'
Uk News

Local MP blocks visit from David Irving's 'secret tour'

Rosa Doherty

Friday, December 2, 2016

Local MP blocks visit from David Irving's 'secret tour'
Uk News

Anti-Israel conference faces delay

Lee Harpin

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Anti-Israel conference faces delay
Uk News

Commission criticised over inquiry into 'antisemitic' charity

Daniel Sugarman

Monday, December 5, 2016

Commission criticised over inquiry into 'antisemitic' charity
Uk News

Fawlty Towers star Andrew Sachs dies aged 86

JC Reporter

Friday, December 2, 2016

Fawlty Towers star Andrew Sachs dies aged 86
Special Reports

Dublin benefits from overseas aid

Barry Toberman

Sunday, January 8, 2017

Dublin benefits from overseas aid
Uk News

Luciana Berger troll driven by 'fierce antisemitism'

JC Reporter

Monday, December 5, 2016

Luciana Berger troll driven by 'fierce antisemitism'
Uk News

UJS presidential candidate abused for pro-BDS s...

Daniel Sugarman

Thursday, December 1, 2016

UJS presidential candidate abused for pro-BDS s...