Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Israel’s settlement policy is ‘destroying’ the country

    A London audience this week voted decisively in favour of a motion that Israel was “destroying itself with its settlement policy”.

    The resolution at a packed public debate was proposed by New Israel Fund board member Daniel Levy, director of the Middle East and North Africa programme at the European Council on Foreign Relations, and William Sieghart, chairman of the dialogue group Forward Thinking.

    Opposing them were Dani Dayan, chairman of Yesha, the Jewish settlers’ council in Judea and Samaria, and Jerusalem Post columnist Caroline Glick.

    Before the start of the event – which was staged by the Intelligence Squared debating forum – the audience voted by 343 for the motion and 97 against, with 192 undecided. By the end, the number in favour had risen to 517, with 99 against and just 31 undecided.

    At one point, the arguments became so heated that the chairman, BBC journalist Tim Franks, had to intervene to restore order on the panel.

    In his presentation, Mr Dayan said that having rejected partition in the past and trying to annihilate the Jewish state by force, the Palestinians had lost the moral right to demand it now.

    Believing Jewish settlement to be “morally impeccable”, he said that without Israeli control of the strategically important hills of Judea and Samaria, only a fence would separate Tel Aviv from an “Islamic fundamentalist territory” stretching all the way to Afghanistan. “That is suicide,” he said.

    Instead of a Palestinian state, he suggested that the territories should eventually be jointly administered by Israel and Jordan.

    “The fact is that a Palestinian stated does not exist even today because of the moral and political decisions made by the Palestinians themselves,” he said.

    But Mr Levy contended that “the single most prohibitive factor to achieving a two-state solution is the settlement enterprise”.

    You can watch the debate on Youtube.

UK News

Anger over Labour Livingstone resignation collusion

Lee Harpin

Thu, 16:22

Anger over Labour Livingstone resignation collusion
UK News

Philip Roth dies aged 85

Daniel Sugarman

Wed, 09:08

Philip Roth dies aged 85
UK News

Sacks defends Mike Pence speechwriting role

Marcus Dysch

Wednesday, January 24, 2018

Sacks defends Mike Pence speechwriting role
UK News

'Hate' metal band dropped from UK tour over 'sick fascination with Nazis'

Rosa Doherty

Daniel Sugarman

Thu, 10:20

'Hate' metal band dropped from UK tour over 'sick fascination with Nazis'
UK News

Israeli-born Tory donor 'to be party's new treasurer'

Lee Harpin

Tue, 15:52

Israeli-born Tory donor 'to be party's new treasurer'
UK News

Hundreds of thousands view Holocaust denial talk

Rosa Doherty

Monday, May 22, 2017

Hundreds of thousands view Holocaust denial talk
UK News

Left-wing blog co-founder 'quits' after followers send David Baddiel antisemitic abuse

Lee Harpin

Wed, 18:57

Left-wing blog co-founder 'quits' after followers send David Baddiel antisemitic abuse
UK News

Strip Jewish group of award, say Labour activists

Marcus Dysch

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Strip Jewish group of award, say Labour activists
UK News

Dublin to fly Palestinian flag

Ben Weich

Thursday, April 6, 2017

Dublin to fly Palestinian flag