Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Baroness Tonge meeting ‘was not antisemitic’, says Lords’ committee

Peer formally apologises over Parliamentary code of conduct breach

    Baroness Tonge
    Baroness Tonge

    Baroness Tonge has formally apologised after being found to have breached the House of Lords’ code of conduct when she hosted an event where Israel was compared to Daesh terrorists.

    However, accusations over antisemitic comments at the event were dismissed by the House of Lords’ Privileges and Conduct Committee.

    Video footage of the event last October showed Baroness Tonge listening to a man who said Zionism was a “perversion of Judaism”. He then implied an American rabbi had provoked Hitler into murdering six million Jews, using quotes reportedly taken from a neo-Nazi website.

    The man – reportedly a member of the anti-Zionist strictly Orthodox Neturei Karta sect – claimed Hitler was “pushed over the edge” by the rabbi’s comments.

    The man went on to talk about boycotts.

    Baroness Tonge is seen on camera thanking the speaker, before adding: “I think it’s very important that the word boycott has come up. The BDS, the campaign to boycott Israeli goods and services, and divestment from Israel, most of us think is very, very important indeed.”

    Run by the Palestinian Return Centre (PRC) and hosted by Baroness Tonge, the meeting saw the launch of the Balfour Apology Campaign, ahead of the centenary of the Balfour Declaration next year.

    The report, published today, concluded that Baroness Tonge, who was suspended and subsequently resigned from the Liberal Democrats after the event, was not guilty of antisemitism.

    Investigators concluded that the meeting had not been intended to promote antisemitism, which meant the peer was “not obliged to deal with any such takeover”, of the event.

    The report states: “The commissioner assessed the detailed content of the meeting hosted by Baroness Tonge against the working definition of antisemitism agreed by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance and adopted by the Government.

    “The commissioner found that the meeting was not hosted with the intention of promoting antisemitism and was not taken over by those promoting antisemitism, so Baroness Tonge was not obliged to deal with any such takeover. The commissioner therefore dismissed this allegation.”

    Instead the committee found the peer had breached the code on a technicality, following complaints about the meeting at Westminster.

    The committee’s report, which followed investigations by the independent House of Lords Commissioner for Standards, found she breached the Code of Conduct by not obtaining the required permission for filming and photography at the event.

    It recommended that she make a written formal apology, which she has since done.

World

Einstein letter thanks American who helped Jews escape Nazi Germany

Jessica Weinstein

09:09

Einstein letter thanks American who helped Jews escape Nazi Germany
UK News

Extent of JLC cover-up revealed

Lee Harpin

Yesterday, 08:00

Extent of JLC cover-up revealed
UK News

JLC to launch Newmark review

Marcus Dysch

Wed, 12:52

JLC to launch Newmark review
UK News

Arkush calls for JLC to 'clean up' its 'mess'

Daniel Sugarman

Yesterday, 16:42

Arkush calls for JLC to 'clean up' its 'mess'
UK News

Labour MPs attend event organised by activists facing antisemitism claims

Marcus Dysch

Wed, 15:56

Labour MPs attend event organised by activists facing antisemitism claims
World

Google, Twitter face Holocaust denial legal action

Rosa Doherty

Tue, 17:46

Google, Twitter face Holocaust denial legal action
UK News

‘Vigilantes’ targeting hard-left

Rosa Doherty

Yesterday, 15:14

‘Vigilantes’ targeting hard-left
UK News

Orthodox leader warns of state threat to religious education

Simon Rocker

Wed, 15:00

Orthodox leader warns of state threat to religious education
UK News

Verber stands down from Board role over family commitments

Daniel Sugarman

Tue, 11:46

Verber stands down from Board role over family commitments