Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Netanyahu against vetting of Supreme Court judges

    The political battle over new laws aimed at limiting foreign funding of human rights organisations and changing Israel's Supreme Court continued to rage this week, with no clear winner emerging.

    The law forbidding "political NGOs" in Israel from receiving funding from foreign governments was proposed by Likud Knesset member Ophir Akunis. The legislation is mainly aimed at left-wing human rights organisations that the right are accusing of "taking money from foreign interests to act against the state".

    On Sunday, the cabinet's legislative committee voted to support the law in the Knesset by 11 votes to five.

    The move came despite warnings from the National Security Adviser that it would harm Israel's international standing. The British Ambassador to Israel, Matthew Gould, also warned Israeli politicians of the damage the law would cause to Israel's diplomatic relations.

    Despite supporting the law in the legislative committee, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pressured MK Akunis to "tone it down" before it is brought to a Knesset vote.

    However, Mr Netanyahu decided to oppose another law proposed by the right-wing that called for open hearings to vet all candidates for the Supreme Court. "Judges will not have to appear for politicians," said Mr Netanyahu, "the independence of the court is paramount."

    But the Prime Minister did not oppose two other controversial laws involving the Supreme Court that passed in the Knesset this week. One of those shortens the minimum period that the president of the court can serve. This will allow the conservative judge Asher Grunis, who is favoured by the right, to be appointed as the next Supreme Court president.

    Another law that passed in its preliminary vote gives the Israeli Bar Association, currently controlled by a left-wing faction, less control over choosing its representatives to the Judicial Appointments Committee that rules on the identity of new judges.

    A number of senior Likud ministers who oppose the laws as "undemocratic" were not present during the votes so as not to defy the coalition whip.

    Infrastructure Minister and Yisrael Beiteinu MK Uzi Landau, who supported the laws, said that they were necessary because "the Supreme Court lacks pluralism. It is elitist, Ashkenazi, political and left-wing and is disconnected from Judaism and sometimes reality. It allows itself to meddle in affairs in which it has no business."

    The law proposals were not only opposed by the centrist and left-wing parties in the Knesset and a small minority of Likud members. President Shimon Peres, in an extremely rare political intervention, expressed his opposition to the laws, which he said "deviate from the democratic principle". The president said that "democracy means serving everyone, not ruling everyone."

Israel

Israel fire eyewitness: 'We were trying to out-...

Orlando Radice

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Israel fire eyewitness: 'We were trying to out-...
Comment

Fidel Castro's paradoxical relationship with Is...

Colin Shindler

Sunday, November 27, 2016

Fidel Castro's paradoxical relationship with Is...
Israel

New cases for the Negev's genetic detective

Nathan Jeffay

Thursday, November 24, 2016

New cases for the Negev's genetic detective
Israel

Meet the rabbi that's making waves

Tim Marshall

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Meet the rabbi that's making waves
Israel

Arabs and Palestinians around the world celebra...

JC Reporter

Friday, November 25, 2016

Arabs and Palestinians around the world celebra...
Israel

Bibi faces probe over subs deal

Anshel Pfeffer

Thursday, November 24, 2016

Bibi faces probe over subs deal
Israel

Israeli navy submarine deal could be sunk

Anshel Pfeffer

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Israeli navy submarine deal could be sunk
Israel

Tens of thousands evacuated as bush fires rage ...

JC Reporter

Thursday, November 24, 2016

Tens of thousands evacuated as bush fires rage ...
Israel

Israeli rabbis, Hamas founder call for peace

Nathan Jeffay

Thursday, November 24, 2016

Israeli rabbis, Hamas founder call for peace