Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

IDF Charedi exemptions row spills on to Jerusalem streets

Police officers were caught on camera attacking protesters and Police Commissioner Ronny Alsheikh said he “felt sick” seeing the footage

 

    The ruling last week by the High Court in Jerusalem on the law regulating the exemptions of Haredi yeshiva students from military service prompted violent clashes on the streets of Israel over the weekend, while also adding impetus to a bold move on changing the country's legal landscape.

    The court ruled eight-to-one that the current law is unconstitutional since it enshrines inequality between Israelis who are drafted to the IDF and those who are allowed to continue studying yeshivas indefinitely. It gave the Knesset 12 months to amend its legislation.

    (Flash 90)


    The Charedi parties, Shas and United Torah Judaism, which are both coalition partners, have demanded that the new law will include an overriding clause, which will make it immune to further intervention by the High Court. But if a legal revolution proposed last Thursday by the leaders of the Jewish Home Party, Education Minister Naftali Bennett and Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked, goes ahead, there may be no need of overriding clauses.

    According the Jewish Home proposal, the Knesset will pass a new “Basic Law of Legislation” which will “restore the balance” of separation of powers in Israel. It would essentially allow the government to create “High-Court-proof” legislation. Israel lacks a formal written constitution but “basic laws” have special status and the new basic law would create a section of Israeli legislation immune to judicial review.

    It is unclear at this point whether this law has sufficient support to pass a Knesset vote. Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud and the strictly Orthodox parties are likely to support it, but Defence Minister Avigdor Lieberman’s Yisrael Beiteinu, while critical of High Court “interventionism”, has said that he supports drafting yeshiva students. Another coalition partner, centrist Kulanu, is opposed to legislation limiting the power of the High Court.

    (Flash 90)


    Meanwhile on Sunday, the streets of Jerusalem were the scenes of clashes between police and  strictly Orthodox protestors. The followers of the Toldot Avraham Yitzhak Hassidic sect, protested the arrest of the son of their Rabbi who had refused to attend a summons by the IDF.

    Police officers were filmed attacking protestors, who called them “Nazis”. Police Commissioner Ronny Alsheikh said on Monday morning that he had “felt sick” seeing the footage and that “if any officer lost control, he will have to account for his actions”.

UK News

Far-left move to control Labour antisemitism hearings panel

Lee Harpin

Yesterday, 09:55

Far-left move to control Labour antisemitism hearings panel
UK News

Arkush tells critics why he supported Trump over Jerusalem

Barry Toberman

Sunday, January 14, 2018

Arkush tells critics why he supported Trump over Jerusalem
World

Jews more likely to develop Parkinson’s

Rosa Doherty

Friday, January 12, 2018

Jews more likely to develop Parkinson’s
UK News

United Synagogue criticises paper over sex offender’s advert

Marcus Dysch

Mon, 15:26

United Synagogue criticises paper over sex offender’s advert
World

Explainer: Five corruption claims against Netanyahu

Anshel Pfeffer

Michael Daventry

Friday, January 12, 2018

Explainer: Five corruption claims against Netanyahu
Community News

Over-40 males: date women your own age

Ben Weich

Friday, January 12, 2018

Over-40 males: date women your own age
UK News

Board to meet Mary Hassell for talk over burials row

Daniel Sugarman

Mon, 12:05

Board to meet Mary Hassell for talk over burials row
Israel

Israel cautions on Palestinian refugee funding

Anshel Pfeffer

Friday, January 12, 2018

Israel cautions on Palestinian refugee funding
Analysis

Israel’s BDS list has a local angle

Anshel Pfeffer

Thursday, January 11, 2018

Israel’s BDS list has a local angle