Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

How to Eat Well: Intolerances put to the test

    Few things divide the nutrition professionals as much as the subject of food intolerances. Over the last decade I have heard of innumerable therapists all too glad to “diagnose” their clients with some food intolerance that is causing any number of symptoms. Many use software that the programmers claim was developed for NASA, although why a space agency would be interested in an astronaut feeling mildly bloated after eating wheat is beyond me.
    The immune system is highly complex. Responses to food involve many different kinds of cells, most notably the immunoglobulins, of which there are a number of types. Food allergies — ie a swift and dramatic response to a particular food — involve immunoglobulin E, or IgE. If you have raised levels of these antibodies in the blood as a result of eating a food, then an allergic reaction is possible.
    Intolerances, as distinct from allergies, involve another Ig, known as IgG. Measuring levels supposedly allows a diagnosis to be made. But there is disagreement about IgG. Many professionals believe that raised levels of IgG simply denote that the body has been exposed to the food, and do not signal an intolerance.
    But the problem goes further than doubts over what the tests tell us. It is my belief that we have become obsessed with food intolerances. As your GP is unlikely to diagnose them, we set off on a journey to find out what might be causing whatever condition we might be suffering from. Intolerance testing is cleverly marketed and implies that everything from fatigue to headaches, as well as weight gain, could be linked to intolerances. Compelling stuff, isn’t it? Who wouldn’t want more energy and weight loss, and even better, something to blame? It wasn’t your poor diet or lack of exercise, it was the wheat/herring/noodles what done it.
    My opinion is that intolerance tests rarely show that the individual doesn’t have an intolerance, not because we all have them, but because the tests are flawed. The main problem is that misplaced and inaccurate diagnoses don’t help the people who do have genuine immune responses to food. Crying wolf doesn’t help anyone.

    www.ianmarber.com

Blogs

Japanese Kit Kats rock my world

The Fresser

Tuesday, May 9, 2017

Japanese Kit Kats rock my world
Blogs

A recipe for better hamantaschen

The Fresser

Saturday, March 18, 2017

A recipe for better hamantaschen
Food

Orange hummus and kim-chi: only at Kosherfest

Dave Gordon

Thursday, November 24, 2016

Orange hummus and kim-chi: only at Kosherfest
Food

Getting haimishe with hygge

Claire Cantor

Friday, April 28, 2017

Getting haimishe with hygge
Food

Fine dining at Israeli hotels offer guilty pleasures

Anthea Gerrie

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Fine dining at Israeli hotels offer guilty pleasures
Food

An alternative manifesto

Anonymous

Thursday, November 17, 2016

An alternative manifesto
Blogs

Pesach breakfast ideas #3 - fruit 'n nut banana...

The Fresser

Friday, April 14, 2017

Pesach breakfast ideas #3 - fruit 'n nut banana...
Food

Vegan shmegan - can an animal-free diet be kosher?

Sandy Rashty

Friday, November 25, 2016

Vegan shmegan - can an animal-free diet be kosher?
Sport news

Milch registers KO in 12th professional victory

Darren Witcoop

Tuesday, November 8, 2016

Milch registers KO in 12th professional victory