Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Theatre review: My Name is Rachel Corrie

The controversial Gaza play lacks the complexity to portray the Israel-Palestinian conflict fairly

Young Vic

    Erin Doherty in My Name Is Rachel Corrie at the Young Vic, London. Photo: Ellie Kurrtz
    Erin Doherty in My Name Is Rachel Corrie at the Young Vic, London. Photo: Ellie Kurrtz Photo: Ellie Kurttz

    Anyone who calls for a play to be banned or attempts to stop it being shown immediately puts themselves on the wrong side of freedom of expression.

    But for those who worry that a bigoted anti-Israelism lies behind the writings of Rachel Corrie, or even those who stage the play, here is some context which may be reassuring.

    There are two plays currently on in London that address the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. One is J T Rogers’s multi award-winning account of how the Oslo peace accords came about, which is currently enjoying a sold out run at the National Theatre before transferring to the West End.

    The other is a revival of this moving monologue first seen in 2005 and adapted by the late Alan Rickman and Katharine Viner (now editor of the Guardian).

    It was chosen by this year’s winner of the JMK Trust Young Director Award Josh Roche. On the whole, the play that reflects the complexity of the conflict, rather than one particular, and possibly anti-Israel, point of view, is winning.

    It might be worth mentioning here that although the Young Vic has not unreasonably defended the decision to stage the play, it wasn’t chosen by them. So what would those opposing the play have the theatre’s outgoing (and, by the way, Jewish) artistic director David Lan do? Say “no" to the young director’s choice?

    None of the controversy surrounding the play - the Zionist Federation’s leafleting campaign outside the Young Vic which attempts to redress what it sees as factual inaccuracies, nor those who doubtless use the play to attack Israel – changes the fact that Corrie’s articulate and lyrical voice is undoubtedly worth preserving.

    And over the play’s uninterrupted 90 minutes the young actor Erin Doherty displays a full command of her subject, transmitting the uncertainty and passion of a figure driven less by facts than by the impulse to act caringly.

    This is a play about the depth of feeling that dries people to activism. It’s a cry against apathy

    But as a political work its limits are plain. Those for and against the play talk a lot about the truths that are included in it and that have been left out of it.

    But when it comes to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, only complexity can get close to a truth. And for that you're far better of going to Oslo.

UK News

Philip Roth dies aged 85

Daniel Sugarman

09:08

Philip Roth dies aged 85
UK News

Livingstone 'told what to say about Zionism row'

Lee Harpin

Yesterday, 09:47

Livingstone 'told what to say about Zionism row'
UK News

Royal wedding has Jewish flavour

Ben Weich

Friday, May 18, 2018

Royal wedding has Jewish flavour
UK News

Ken Livingstone: Why I quit Labour

Rosa Doherty

Yesterday, 16:38

Ken Livingstone: Why I quit Labour
UK News

Livingstone quits Labour

Lee Harpin

Mon, 21:01

Livingstone quits Labour
UK News

Muslim group buys newspaper adverts to fight antisemitism

Daniel Sugarman

Friday, May 18, 2018

Muslim group buys newspaper adverts to fight antisemitism
UK News

Frankie Boyle claims Israel jokes were censored

Lee Harpin

Yesterday, 12:05

Frankie Boyle claims Israel jokes were censored
US News

Concentration camp Judaica is sold at auction

Anthea Gerrie

Sunday, May 20, 2018

Concentration camp Judaica is sold at auction
Theatre

Theatre review: Red

John Nathan

Friday, May 18, 2018

Theatre review: Red