Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Review: Primal Scream

Scream if you've heard it all before

More Light (Ignition)

    Familiar shades: Primal Scream
    Familiar shades: Primal Scream

    It is 22 years since Primal Scream released a truly important album (Screamadelica) and 13 years since their last great one (XTRMNTR). The former captured the heady moment when house music entered the mainstream; the latter was the most successful example of the band’s rampant eclecticism.

    On More Light, their 10th album, the Primals once again offer a précis of their favourite artists’ careers — not for nothing has their disparate approach been described as “record collection rock”. Trouble is, it comes across less like a band with a unique voice and more like a bunch of copycats offering karaoke renditions of their heroes’ classics.

    The problems with More Light start with the album opener, 2013, which desperately wants to be a generational rallying cry along the lines of the Stooges’ epochal 1969. The effect is comical rather than revolutionary, not least because frontman Bobby Gillespie is a 51-year-old Glaswegian rather than a 21-year-old from Detroit.

    Culturecide refers to neutron bombs and satellite dishes, although as ever with Gillespie it feels as though he’s just name-checking pop-cultural totems rather than making a serious point. More impressive is the mix of influences. You can detect elements of everyone from Roxy Music to Funkadelic.

    Elsewhere, there are echoes of John Lennon circa the Plastic Ono Band, New York synth-punk duo Suicide and the cosmic grooves of 70s German experimentalists Can. As a redux version of a cool vinyl collection, it works a treat. But it’s more likely to send you back to the musicians being mimicked than to elevate the Scream to their status.

Obituaries

Obituary: Leonard Cohen

Gloria Tessler

Tuesday, November 22, 2016

Obituary: Leonard Cohen
Music

The family who are always in harmony

Jessica Duchen

The family who are always in harmony
Music

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature

Stoddard Martin

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature
Music

Teenage family trio get set for double premiere...

Anonymous

Teenage family trio get set for double premiere...
Music

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera

Jessica Duchen

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera
Music

Crossing borders in music and life

Jessica Duchen

Crossing borders in music and life
Music

She's 90, but the music keeps playing

Anonymous

She's 90, but the music keeps playing
Music

A triumph of Dylanology

Bryan Cheyette

A triumph of Dylanology
Music

The classical star inspired by astrology

Rosa Doherty

The classical star inspired by astrology