Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Opera review - Die Frau ohne Schatten (Royal Opera House): This Strauss in the House is as good as it gets

    A scene from Die Frau ohne Schatten
    A scene from Die Frau ohne Schatten

    How’s this for a 20th-century plot? A supernatural Empress is married to a human Emperor who will be turned to stone if the Empress is not able to buy a shadow from a poor woman. And those are just the basic elements.
    Strauss’s Die Frau ohne Schatten is sometimes described as his response to The Magic Flute.

    Underneath it lies the same idea of a test of worthiness. But where Mozart’s opera can be seen on one level almost as pantomime, this is so heavily allegorical and suffused with psychological ambiguity that it defeats almost all directors.

    Claus Guth’s solution is to treat it all as the sexually charged dream of a frustrated young wife. The device works, so that focus is directed away from the more creaking elements of the plot.

    But if I urge you to see this new production, it’s not because of the staging, excellent as that is. It’s because you will never hear a finer performance of a Strauss opera than the blazing, incandescent, tender and opulent reading of the glorious score that Semyon Bychkov secures from the Royal Opera House orchestra. On this evidence, we have the Vienna and Berlin philharmonics rolled into one in the Covent Garden pit.

    Too often, gorgeous orchestral performances of Strauss are let down by barking from the singers. Not here. The five principals are sensational — every note is pitch perfect and musical. As the Empress, Emily Magee’s soprano floats above the orchestra. And Elena Pankratova is dramatically compelling as the Wife. Michaela Schuster’s Nurse is the lynchpin of the production and is even better than her recent Klytaemnestra.

    Emperor Johan Botha’s pure, ringing heldentenor tone seems from a bygone age and Johan Reuter’s Barak completes a simply perfect cast.

    This is as good as it gets.

Music

She's 90, but the music keeps playing

Anonymous

Thursday, November 17, 2016

She's 90, but the music keeps playing
Music

A triumph of Dylanology

Bryan Cheyette

Friday, October 21, 2016

A triumph of Dylanology
Music

The classical star inspired by astrology

Rosa Doherty

Thursday, October 6, 2016

The classical star inspired by astrology
Music

The family who are always in harmony

Jessica Duchen

Thursday, November 10, 2016

The family who are always in harmony
Music

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature

Stoddard Martin

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature
Music

Craig's bid for a serious comeback

Elisa Bray

Thursday, September 29, 2016

Craig's bid for a serious comeback
Music

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera

Jessica Duchen

Friday, October 21, 2016

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera
Music

Crossing borders in music and life

Jessica Duchen

Thursday, October 13, 2016

Crossing borders in music and life
Music

Sophie finds her voice - in Russia

Joseph Finlay

Thursday, September 29, 2016

Sophie finds her voice - in Russia